|
Sent in by Peter Wishart, one of our site visitors The whole of this issue of our newspaper deals with the events of 10th May and the subsequent weeks following the disaster. The first article is a very special one from Mr. Paterson. COLLIERY GENERAL MANAGER'S REPORTAs you are all aware, on the 10th May, 1973, Seafield Colliery was struck by a tragic disaster. In D. 22, as a result of a large roof fall, five of our fellow work-mates lost their lives. This was tragic for us, for the industry and for the Community as a whole but particularly hard for the relatives and close friends of these 5 men. The waiting must have been particularly hard for Mrs. Guthrie and Mrs. Kilpatrick. If we can derive some comfort from the tragedy, it was the escape of Jimmy Todd, Eddie Downes, David Dickson and John McCartney. This is particularly so in the case of John, who escaped from 120 chock and made his way to the Top Road (Tail Gate) unaided despite the serious injuries he received. I would like to take this opportunity of thanking men, officials and management for their unstinting assistance during the 4 week period of the accident. I must specially thank some people - those who at great risk to themselves carried out the rescue operation on Thursday night. I think the words of David Dickson sum up our feelings - " When I came out of the chocks and saw the conditions these rescuers had worked in, I thought to myself - imagine them doing this to get me out ". I must also say a special word of thanks to those workmen, officials and management who, for four weeks, worked a 4-shift, 7-day-week in an attempt to recover Angus and Tom. They worked unceasingly in difficult and dangerous conditions to recover their workmates. The actual recovery of the bodies was not a pleasant task but they got on with the job in a typical Seafield manner. The fact that two of their workmates had not been recovered did not deter everyone in the Colliery from carrying on with their normal work and I am sure there has never been a disaster of this kind where, on the week following, the Colliery produced 20,000 tons of coal. I am not surprised as this is what I would have expected from the team spirit which exists at Seafield. This is the spirit which, although we will never forget the accident, will make our pit the best in Scotland once again, if not the best in Britain. Even if it is never the best in Britain for output, I will always recognise it as the best for courage and determination and I am proud to be the Captain of a team that performs in this way. I would also like to thank the Trade Unions for their help and assistance during this troublesome period. This was only further evidence of the spirit of co-operation which we have known to exist at Seafield. Everyone got on with their job in a cool, calm manner and nobody showed any sign of panic that might well have existed during this time. On your behalf, I would like to publicy record our thanks to Jim Ritchie and Max Meharry for their unpleasant task they performed in informing the relatives of the deceased. This is not an easy task and one made more difficult by the fact that Angus and Tom were some time in being recovered. I can assure you that no points are being missed in attempting to uncover the basic cause of the accident. There are many theories going around at the present time but, so far, nothing concrete has emerged. It would be wrong of any of us to attempt to theorise or to draw any conclusions until all the facts have been ascertained and this is what we are doing at the moment. Thank you once again for all your efforts and assistance and I look forward to the very near future when we will see fruition of all these efforts. DAVID T. PATERSON 2. LETTER FROM MR. J. R. COWAN, DIRECTOR I was deeply shocked to learn of the disaster at Seafield. I visited the Colliery on many occasions and examined the disaster site with Mr. McGahey, President, N.U.M, and was most impressed by the skills and the dedication of men and officials working in that area. Everyone at the Colliery - men, management and Trade Unions - deserve to be congratulated on the responsible and single mindedness of attitude adopted, in the most trying circumstances. Whatever lessons have to be learned from the Public Inquiry which will take place in August, I'm convinced the spirit I saw at Seafield Colliery over the past weeks will pay dividends in the future. OBITUARY The men killed in the disaster on 10th May in D. 22 are :- ROBERT HENDERSON Born 14/6/13, resided at 42 Factory Road, Buckhaven. Bobby leaves a widow and grown-up family. "Heelplates" as he was known, came to Seafield from Wellesley Colliery when Wellesley closed. He spent his whole life in mining and gained his nick-name at Wellesley. He was on a brushing job and boasting about the excellent job he was doing. When it was discovered by his mates that the roadway girders were the small 6' x 6' size, he was banteringly told he was only erecting heelplates and the name stuck. Bobby was actually alive when rescued but died on the stretchers. JAMES HOLMES Born 27/4/20, resided at 6 Beech Avenue, Methil. He also leaves a widow and a grown-up family, all working. Unfortunately, his oldest son, who works as a deck-hand on a Shell tanker, was unable to get home for his Dad's funeral. He was on a tanker in the middle of the Pacific Ocean. JAMES COMRIE Born 26/3/24, resided at 44 Barncraig Street, Buckhaven. James leaves a widow and 2 grown-up sons. A miner through and through, Jimmy was on the Management Committee of Denbeath Miners' Welfare and was Vice-President of their Bowling Club. He was, in fact, a member of the Fife Team in the Scottish Championships held at Queen's Park last year. ANGUS GUTHRIE Born 26/5/52 resided with his widowed mother at 73 Carden Castle Park, Cardenden. Angus was only 2 weeks short of his 21st birthday. His family has a mining background and his father died 8 years ago from pneumoconiosis. Angus himself was going through the Industry's Technical Training Scheme and attended Lauder College, Cowdenbeath, as a Board student. A very likeable lad, Angus was a great favourite with all his mates. He was a member of the Junior Safety Quiz Team and, in fact, the day of the disaster was his last shift that week as he was due to travel to Harrogate on Friday morning to support Seafield Quiz Team in the Regional Final. His mother, brothers and sister, had a most trying time as Angus's body was not recovered until Saturday, 19th May, some 9 days after the disaster. 3. OBITUARY (cont.) THOMAS KILPATRICK Born21/4/35, resided at 11 Walnut Crescent, Methil. Tom leaves a widow, Christina, and 3 daughters, Avril, Karen and Sandra, all at school. Tom was a keen outdoors-man and was a member of the Eden Wildflowers Club. He also had an alsation, Cheri. Outwith the shock of Tom's death, his widow and family had the prolonged heartbreak of waiting 4 weeks before his body was recovered. "Tom-Cat" as Tom was known, had a large circle of friends, including his team-mates on D. 22 faceline. As each funeral took place, a massive turn-out from the Colliery, senior Board and Union Officials and people from all walks of life, including the MP for Kirkcaldy, the Convenor of Fife County Council, Senior Police Officials, etc. In the Crematoriums, the services had to be relayed to huge crowds outside who could not get in. The thanks of the families and relatives of the deceased are best summed up in printing the following letters sent to the Colliery by Mrs. Christina Kilpatrick, widow of Tom. 11 Walnut Crescent METHIL 12/6/73 Dear Mr Paterson Will you please convey my deepest thanks to everyone concerned in the rescue operations to recover the body of my late husband, Tom Kilpatrick. I would especially like to thank all the members of the rescue teams who worked for so long, at the risk of their own lives, to effect the recovery. I would like to express my thanks to the Reverend Mr. Proudfoot for his visits and words of comfort, and Mr. Max Meharry for keeping us informed of progress and many kind words and deeds during the long days of waiting. Yours sincerely (Sgd) MRS. CHRISTINA KILPATRICK. Dear Mr. Paterson and Mr. Ritchie Will you please accept my sincere thanks for the cheque of £450 which I received from the N.C.B and N.U.M. Fatal Accident Fund. Yours sincerely (Sgd) MRS CHRISTINA KILPATRICK Editors Note: the cheques from the Special Fatal Accident Fund we delivered to the dependants of all the deceased 8 days after the disaster. 4. THOUGHTS OF A MEMBER OF THE RECOVERY TEAM
Arriving on D. 22 face-line at 8.30 p.m., my first reaction was "There's nobody alive in that mess of redd, rock, rubble, steel, hoses and chocks", but I stifled my fears. Hope still clings to rescuer and entombed. Inching our way, like cats stalking a kill, careful to disturb nothing, we start the search, each nerve pinging like an Asdic receiver, as we strain eyes and ears for some sign of life in that silent Hell. Hope is fading and flagging, muscles seem heavy when suddenly we hear a shout. There is immediate upsurge of effort. Men we thought average become supermen. Stones and rock are tossed to the side like confetti at a wedding in the team's agonised efforts to reach their mates. Steady now, we're getting near, and suddenly we are through to the first man. as gently as a midwife delivering a baby, the rescuers free the first to be rescued. On to the stretchers with him while his lamp and check number are phoned to the surface. In a few minutes good news will be on its way to anxious and worried dependants. Back to the mountain of collapsed face and the next cries we hear are under our feet. Is it luck or some other power that has kept the next two men from death? I don't know but somehow men are still alive and the tempo increases in the desperate struggle to get them out. The position looks hopeless but, unbelievably, we get two men out quickly and the elation of the rescuers is really something special. Time is running out, ominous creeks come from the exposed roof far above us but something in the mind keeps you from dwelling on your own safety. As long as there's a chance we keep on trying, ignoring what's above us. Another light is uncovered and the man is alive. Very gently the rubble is cleared from around him. The cry goes up for a knife and one is quickly passed down to cut away the man's lamp battery. Slowly we lift the body out and onto the stretchers. In a strained voice the man stammers out his thanks to the rescuers, shuddered and died. There is a stunned silence amongst the rescuers. The whole situation is completly unreal. A huge cavern, the darkness penetrated by the pencils of light from workmen, is reminiscent of an air-raid alert in wartime, with searchlights slicing the black sky. I've never seen death before. I feel terrified but I can't tear my gaze away from that still figure on the stretchers. " Christ Almighty", he can't be dead. He was speaking to us as we freed him. But as the still face and sightless eyes were covered over by a blanket, the realisation sank in. A shocked silence, then our stillness was broken by the Undermanagers cry "I can see another light". Everyone is galvanised into action. We are riding on the crest of hope. This man is speaking to us all the time. Same drill as before. Cut away his lamp, smoke mask, etc., and clear away the debris with our hands. Ever so gentle he is extricated, eased from that hell-hole like a cork from a bottle. He is still speaking away. Our hearts expand with pride in achievement. We win part of this death-cheat operation. But fate was not so easily defeated. The rescued man's voice weakened, his mouth worked as he tried to form words, then a curious stillness stole over his face. His body seemed to shrink and slacken and we knew, without diagnosis, that we had lost him. I feel extremely bitter. All that effort and he slipped away from us, just like switching off a light but you can't switch a life on again. Before I can recriminate any more, another shout informs us another light can be seen, but our hopes are dashed as word comes that the man is obviously dead. Still, we follow the same routine and eventually we get the body eased out with a reverence that would do credit to an Archbishop. 5. I glance around me and I'm surprised at the number of additional people that have turned up. Some obviously are from Her Majesty's Mines Inspectorate and others are senior Board Officials. I don't know how long they have been there, perhaps they've been with us all the time. Our concentration was on rescue work and nothing else. Obvious consultations are going on and finally we are told to stop work. Conditions have deteriorated badly and the view is expressed that to stay as we are would endanger the lives of the rescuers. There is no one else alive in that mess. Reluctant though we are to leave, we face reality. No useful purpose can be served by staying where we are. Silently, each man a prisoner of his own thoughts, we trudge out to the man-riding bogies. I feel physically exhausted, mentally-depressed and emotionally-drained. Four men out alive, 3 bodies recovered and 2 men still entombed with all hope abandoned. You read about disasters like this but they are impersonal because you are not involved. I never thought for a moment this would happen at our pit. Nature has proved yet again that she won't give up her wealth without exacting some toll in return. The ride to the pit bottom is jolting and monotonous but eventually we arrive and climb out of the cars stiffly, the sweat dried to cold clamminess clutching my body. The cage is ready and we enter and start the ascent to the surface. The cage arrives at the pit top and I'm stunned. It's like as if an electrical storm was taking place with soundless flashes going on incessantly. As my red-rimmed eyes blink to adjust the daylight, I realise the flashes are from the hordes of press photographers. Reporters, long-haired and pencils poised, fire rapid questions with indelicacy born from long practice. "What's it like down there"? One asks me. My reply will never appear in print, that's certain. I feel slightly sick. We're news, not because we broke production records but because 5 miners died today. Our misfortunes are someone else's morning headlines. A twinge of remorse, I read the paper yesterday with no thoughts other than general interest in the misfortunes of others. I plod mechanically through the lamp room, past the Time Office and into the baths, clutching the free meal ticket put in my hand by an overly considerate Time Office Clerk. I undress and get into the showers. I'm exhausted and sit on the floor allowing the spary to cascade on my head and over my whole body and I'm reluctant to leave the comfort of the showers. I get dried and dress slowly, slightly afraid of having nothing to do but think. I make my way from the Baths and hesitate at the door of the crowded Canteen. I'm not really hungry so I turn away and go outside to the Car Park. The whole place is crowded with strangers. In a detatched way, I notice B.B.C. and S.T.V. vying with each other for information and pictures. The sun has risen above the skyline and the Forth is at high tide and as still as a mirror. I can see Cockenzie Power Station gleaming white and smoking in the distance. What a morning for Death. Five dead, four safe. There will be sad hearts in Fife today. My despondency lingers but reason finally asserts itself. By all accounts no one should have come out alive from that holocaust. Yes, that's it. My shoulders square back imperceptibly and my spirits lift. We did our best and we won, no one will deny us that. As I reach my car I feel better. Yes, we in this pit can walk tall and look the world straight in the eye. 6. CONDOLENCES Letters and telegrams of sympathy were sent to the pit from people and organisations representing the whole strata of our society. Space does not permit us to print all the messages but here are as many as possible. 1. PRIME MINISTER "I was very sorry indeed to learn of the tragic disaster at the Seafield Colliery. I should be grateful if you would convey my deep sympathy to the families of those who have lost their lives" 2 D. EZRA, CHAIRMAN, NATIONAL COAL BOARD "I would be grateful if you would pass on my thanks to all those who have taken part in the rescue and recovery operations at Seafield Colliery. I have nothing but admiration for the quiet determined effort and bravery of those who have toiled for so long during this work. The tragedy was a great shock to us all but we drew some comfort and inspiration from the selfless dedication displayed at Seafield". 3 SECRETARY OF STATE FOR SCOTLAND - GORDON CAMPBELL "I was shocked to hear of the tragedy at Seafield Colliery. everyone in Scotland will, with me, wish to convey sympathy to the relatives of the bereaved and appreciation of the efforts of the Rescue Teams". 4 EUROPEAN COAL & STEEL COMMUNITY - P. HILLARY "Deeply grieved to hear of the disaster at your mine. Please accept our sincere condolences on behalf of the European Commision and myself. The Commision sympathies with the families in their misfortune". 5 COUNT VICTOR MATUSCHA, GERMAN CONSULATE GENERAL "I learned with deep sorrow of the loss of lives in the Seafield Colliery and would wish to convey my sympathies to you and the relatives of the bereaved." 6 PERSONAL VISIT BY HARRY GOURLAY, MP, KIRKCALDY BURGHS. MINERS' UNION BRANCHES From Mr. & Mrs. David Bolton, Vice-President, N.U.M. Scottish Area. From Valleyfield Branch N.U.M. From Guy Stobbs on behalf of Ayrshire Branch From Castlehill Branch N.U.M. From Sherwood Branch N.U.M. Notts Branch From Cowdenbeath Branch SCEBTA " NACODS ( Scottish Area ) From COSLA ( Scottish Branch ) " Kent Coalfields From Seaham Branch, N.U.M. Durham OTHER UNIONS From Transport & General Workers - Dundee, Dunfermline and Buckhaven Equity ( Action Trade Union). PROVOSTS, COUNCILS & POLITICAL PARTIES. Fife County Council Provost Turpie on behalf of Leven Provost Kay on behalf of Kirkcaldy Kirkcaldy Constituency Labour Party Ayrshire Constituency Labour Party Fife Labour Group & Glenrothes L.P Scottish Conservative Party Scottish National Party Scottish District of the Communist Party 7, CONDOLENCES (cont.) From Bowhill Pipe Band Kirkcaldy Round Table McDonald, Timber Merchants, Inverness Electrical, Electronic and Telecommunications Union Scottish Old Age Pensioners Association Stanmills College, Belfast Lt. Col. C. H. MacFetridge Balwearie School Parish Church of St. Columba's, Burntisland St. Andrews Ambulance Corps Hundreds more letters and telegrams were received by the N.U.M and by Kirkcaldy Council. ------------------------------------------ SPECIAL MENTION Correctly so, the colliery as a whole has received the acclamation of the Board, Trade Union leaders, and the general public for its principled, responsible attitude during and following the disaster. Some special thanks are due to certain groups within and without the pit and the following list as an attempt to do so. To the Canteen Manageress and her staff who worked 24 hours a day, 7 days a week to provide meals and snacks. To E. Reekie and Alexanders Bus Co., for their co-operation in providing transport at all and any hour of the day and night. To the Pit Chaplain, Mr Proudfoot, who remained at the Colliery until the sma' hours of 11th May and who visited the families of the bereaved with condolences. To Father Rodger and Father Saddler of Kirkcaldy who came to the Colliery and offered any assistance they could although none of the deceased were of their religion. To Kirkcaldy Round Table Society for help given in a very special case. To Salvation Army for offers of assistance and visits paid to families of the deceased. To the Time Office Staff for an excellent job of checking and administration which proved invaluable in ensuring the names and addresses of all involved in the disaster were absolutely correct. To my own staff, Geo. Blackwood, John Campbell, John Chalmers, and to Alex. Justice, Head Timekeeper and J. Ritchie, N.U.M. delegate, who gave their time and assistance in the heart-breaking tasks necessary in the aftermath of the disaster. To the Police for their help and offers of assistance. To the local Trade Union Committees without whose help recovery and work-resumption would not have taken place. To the Control Room Staff for their efficiency in the first few hours after the disaster until the the Incident Room was set up. To the Safety Quiz Team who travelled to Harrogate two days after the disaster and successfully competed, despite their own personel feelings. It should be noted they donated their prize money to the Disaster Fund. To many, many others who offered help and services in the aftermath of the disaster, sincere thanks. 8, SHORT SHEARS H.M. Inspectorate carried out a preliminary investigation at the colliery and interviewed witnesses to the disaster. All the Trade Unions were represented at the highest level at this preliminary investigation. ------------------------------------------------- Jim Todd, one of the rescued men, remembers clutching his St. Christopher medal during his period of waiting to be rescued. When he woke up in hospital, his hand was still clenched but there was nothing in it and his medal had disappeared. When he came out of hospital, his mother bought him a new one. However, the rescue workers, continuing their efforts to locate Tom Kilpatrick's body, came across the medal under tons of rubble. The medal, all scratched, has been handed back to Jim, who, in turn, presented it to his mother. Was it luck, coincidence, or something else? |