Star Coal Company

Eric Gourlay, Thornton, Fife, is a grandson of James Gourlay, one of the five miners who formed The Star Coal Company in the 1920s. Eric has kindly sent us copies of the mining lease and the agreement which contain the terms of the venture. With his permission, we are pleased to present the content of these documents.
M. Martin & Webmasters



Copy/-

MINUTE OF AGREEMENT

between

William Annandale, Alexander
Wishart, John Grierson, James
Gourlay and Thomas Grieve
Rutherford.

- - - -
1922.

The Star Coal Company.


JAMES THOMSON,
SOLICITOR,
KIRKCALDY

MINUTE of AGREEMENT
between
WILLIAM ANNANDALE, ALEXANDER WISHART, JOHN
GRIERSON, JAMES GOURLAY and THOMAS GRIEVE
RUTHERFORD; all Miners, Star, Markinch.


WHEREAS the parties hereto are the whole individual partners of the Star Coal Company, Star, Markinch, and having entered or being about to enter into a lease with Mrs. Margaret Reid or Brown, Widow, Star, Markinch, and William Wallace Brown, Joiner and Farmer, Star, Markinch, with regard to minerals, &c., in a field known as "The Common", Star, and having made various arrangements in connection with their rights in said Company and it being right and proper that these arrangements should be reduced to writing the parties hereto hereby agree as follows, vist:-

First:-
The parties hereto shall be equally interested in the capital and profits of The Star Coal Company and shall also be liable equally for losses and they shall not be bound to divide profits from time to time unless they all agree to do so.

Second:-
The parties hereto shall be entitled to wages at the same rate and shall work similar hours and in the event of any of the partners being ill and not able to work they shall be paid wages at the same rate as the other partners for the first four weeks and thereafter at the rate of One pound per week so long as they are unable to work through illness but no longer than the termination of this Agreement.

Third:-
In the event of any of the partners wishing to withdraw from the partnership he shall be entitled to do so on giving the other partners four week's written notice of his intention to do so and in that case he shall receive Twenty five pounds in full of his share and accrued profits if the withdrawal takes place prior to the break in said lease at Whitsunday Nineteen hundred and twenty six and if said lease is continued after that date and the withdrawal takes place before Whitsunday Nineteen hundred and twenty seven Thirty pounds, before Whitsunday Nineteen hundred and twenty eight Thirty five pounds, before Whitsunday Nineteen hundred and twenty nine Forty pounds, before Whitsunday Nineteen hundred and thirty Forty five pounds and before Whitsunday Nineteen hundred and thirty one Fifty pounds, all in full of his share and accrued profits and he shall have no further claim on the Company and said sums shall be paid in equal instalments at three, six, nine and twelve months from the date of his withdrawing from the partnership; Not more than one of the partners shall be entitled to withdraw from the partnership before the break in the lease at Whitsunday Nineteen hundred and twenty six unless agreed to by the whole of the remaining partners and not more than one of the partners shall be entitled to withdraw from the partnership between Whitsunday Nineteen hundred and twenty six whether one has withdrawn previously or not; And in the event of any partner leaving the partnership except as above provided or refusing to work while he is able to do so he shall thereby forfeit all interest in the partnership.

Fourth:-
In the event of the death of any of the partners through illness the equal share falling to him shall be calculated by the remaining partners after taking everything into account and his share shall be paid to his representatives in equal instalments at three, six, nine and twelve months from the date of death but without any interest thereon.

Fifth:-
In the event of there being any disagreement amongst the partners and the majority of the partners decide (during the currency of this Agreement) to expel a partner they shall be entitled to do so, on giving his one week's notice in writing of their intention to do so and without any formal meeting being held and the share of such partner in the Company shall be ascertained by John Provan, Colliery Manager, Coaltown of Balgonie, Markinch, whom failing by David Spiers, Under Manager, Julian Cottages, Thornton, whom failing by any other Colliery Manager or Under Manager to be appointed by the salaried Sheriff Substitute of Fife and Kinross at Kirkcaldy on application by any of the parties interested as sole Arbitor and the decision of such Arbitor as payable to such partner shall be paid in equal instalments at three, six, nine and twelve months from the date of his being expelled without interest and each party shall pay their own expense in connection with the arbitration and one-half of the fee to the Arbiter and such partner shall have no further claim on the Company.

Sixth:-
In the event of any of the partners being injured while at work in connection with the Company they shall be paid at the ordinary rate of wages for the first four weeks and after that they shall be paid a sum equal to that which they would have received under the Workmen's Compensation Act if they had been ordinary workmen in the employment of the Company; And in the event of any of the partners being killed while at work with the Company or dying as the result of an accident while at work with the Company their representatives shall be entitled to an amount equal to what they would have received as Compensation under the Workmen's Compensation Act if such partner had been a workman in the employment of the Company but said sum shall be payable by weekly instalments of One pound and shall not bear interest.

Seventh:
In the event of the majority of the partners deciding to give up said lease as at the term of Whitsunday Nineteen hundred and twenty six this Agreement shall then for the purpose of Clause Second be held to have terminated and the assets over after taking everything into account shall be divided amongst the then partners equally and if they continue to carry on the lease for the remaining five years to Whitsunday Nineteen hundred and thirty one this Agreement shall then for the purpose of Clause Second be held to have terminated and they shall then be entitled to the assets equally amongst them unless they make further arrangements with reference to the carrying on of said Company.

Eighth:-
In the event of any partner withdrawing, being expelled, forfeiting his rights in the Company or dying, the remaining partners from time to time shall be entitled to the whole capital and profits equally.

Ninth:-
The partnership shall not be dissolved by the withdrawal, death, expulsion or forfeiture of any partners share in the Company or by the bankruptcy of any partner and in the event of any partner becoming bankrupt his creditors shall only be entitled to the sum which he would have received if he had withdrawn from the partnership and payable in the same way and manner as provided for in that event and in the event of the withdrawal, expulsion or death of a partner or his share in the Company being forfeited, the remaining partners shall then free and relieve him or his representatives of the claims under said lease but shall not be bound to obtain an actual release of such obligations. IN WITNESS THEREOF these presents typed on this and the three preceding pages are subscribed by the whole parties hereto at Star on the Eighth day of July Nineteen hundred and twenty two as follows, vist:- by the said William Annandale, John Grierson, James Gourlay and Thomas Grieve Rutherford before these witnesses; James Thomson, Solicitor, Kirkcaldy and the said William Wallace Brown; and by the said Alexander Wishart before these witnesses; Mrs. Joan Maxwell or Brown, wife of the said William Wallace Brown and the said William Wallace Brown.


(Sgd.) James Thomson, Winness (Sgd.) Wm. Annandale.
“ Wm. W. Brown, Witness. “ Alex. Wishart.
“ Joan Brown, Witness. “ John Grierson.
“ Wm. W. Brown, Witness. “ James Gourlay.
“ Thos. Grieve Rutherford.



Copy/-

L E A S E
between
Mrs. Margaret Reid or Brown,
William W. Brown,

and

Star Coal Co.

- - - -

1922.

Minerals in field known as
Common, Star
JAMES THOMSON,
SOLICITOR,
KIRKCALDY

IT IS CONTRACTED and AGREED between Mrs. MARGARET REID or BROWN, Widow, Star, Markinch and WILLIAM WALLACE BROWN, Joiner and Farmer, Star, Markinch, (hereinafter referred to as "the First Parties") of the First Part and The STAR COAL COMPANY, Star, Markinch, (hereinafter referred to as "the tenants") of the Second Part in the manner following - That is to say, the said First parties for their respect; give rights and interests in consideration of the rent, lordships and other prestations hereinafter mentioned hereby sets and in tack and assedation lets to the tenants but excluding assignees and subtenants legal or conventional, creditors and trustees, or managers for creditors of every description (1) ALL and WHOLE one quarter of an acre Imperial Measure or thereby in the north west corner of the field known as "the Common" and (2) ALL and WHOLE the seams of coal lying in or under the said field known as "the Common" and extending to about three and a half acres Imperial Measure or thereby and lying in the Parish of Kennoway and County of Fife: But EXCEPTING and RESERVING ALWAYS the minerals along the sides of the public roads leading from Star to Kennoway and from that road to Coaltown of Burnturk in so far as the working of such minerals is contrary to law or beyond the power of the First Parties to grant, the tenants being entitled to work the same alongside the said roads in so far as the first Parties may legally work the same and subject to the same conditions in all respects: Provided that in the event of the tenants working within five yards of said roads they shall be bound securely to pack and underbuild the ground so as to prevent so far as possible damage occurring to the said roads, notwithstanding the use of such precautions they shall be liable therefor and shall be bound to relieve the First Parties of all claims in connection therewith: And that for the period of ten years from and after the term of Whitsunday Nineteen hundred and twenty one notwithstanding the date hereof; Declaring that it shall be in the power of the tenants to terminate this lease at the term of Whitsunday Nineteen hundred and twenty six upon giving at least six months previous notice in writing to the First Parties of their intention so to do; And declaring further that this right and liberty shall supersede any right which the tenants might have claimed to abandon this lease on the ground that the minerals hereby let are unworkable to profit, or on any other legal ground or pretext whatever, all rights of which nature they hereby expressly renounce and discharge; And in the event of the tenants taking advantage of the above break in their favour they shall be bound at the time of giving up this lease to fulfil all the obligations which would have been incumbent on them at the natural expiration thereof in the same manner as if it had come to a conclusion by the lapse of the full period thereof; Which subjects are hereby let with power to the tenants at their own expense to search for, bore, dig, work, win, carry away and dispose of the coal hereby let and to sink pits on the quarter acre of ground first hereby let and also to erect engines and machinery and to make roads and other erections necessary upon said quarter acre of ground; As also power to deposit minerals or debris upon said quarter acre of ground with a fence not less than four feet high, of such construction as to exclude cattle and sheep and to keep same in good repair during the currency of this lease and said fence shall be erected not later than Martinmas Nineteen hundred and twenty two; WHICH TACK with and under the conditions and reservations herein contained the First Parties bind and oblige themselves and their heirs and successors to warrant at all hands; For which causes and on the other part, the tenants bind and oblige themselves all jointly and severally and their respective heirs and successors to pay to the said William Wallace Brown and his foresaids (1) Four pounds ten shillings as the agreed on value of the crop on said quarter acre of ground but which has already been paid; (2) One pound ten shillings yearly for the surface of said quarter acre of ground payable half yearly at Martinmas and Whitsunday - the rent up to Martinmas Nineteen hundred and twenty one having been paid, and the tenants further bind themselves all jointly and severally to pay to the said Mrs. Margaret Reid or Brown during her lifetime and after her decease to the said William Wallace Brown and his heirs a lordship of Nine pence per ton for each ton of Twenty hundredweights of unscreened coal or triping sold or removed from the lands in which the said coal is hereby let which lordships shall be payable quarterly on Twenty eighth August, Twenty eighth November, Twenty eighth February and Twenty eighth May in each year or as soon thereafter as the lordships can be ascertained; Declaring that with a view of ascertaining the exact yearly produce or return from the minerals hereby let the tenants shall at their own expense when required by the First Parties erect a well-constructed and suitable steelyard with index lever for weighing the said minerals hereby let as they come from the pit and said steelyard shall be kept by the tenants in constant repair and in a correct and accurate state to the satisfaction of the First Parties and the tenants shall keep regular books and shall enter or cause to be entered daily therein accurate detailed accounts of the weight of the whole minerals put out and removed from the said lands, and the said books and accounts shall be exhibited to the First Parties or their Agent or any other person having their authority when required and may take copies and excerpts therefrom; And the tenants bind and oblige themselves jointly and severally if and when required by the First Parties or their Agent to fill up all pits which may be wrought out or abandoned or which may be no longer of use for the purposes of the works: BUT DECLARING that the tenants shall not be entitled to fill up such pits without the previous written consent of the First Parties or their Agent: And the tenants bind and oblige themselves jointly and severally and their foresaids to pay and free and relieve the First Parties of all damage of every kind caused by or arising from any of their operations whether the same shall happen above or below ground, and whether occasioned to the surface of the ground or the mineral workings, ALSO to pay and free and relieve the First Parties of all damage done to private and public roads, drains by or through any of the several operations hereby authorised; And the tenants bind and oblige themselves at the expiry or sooner termination of this lease to leave the whole mines, levels and wall fences, except in wrought out or abandoned pits and seams, open and well ventilated; And within six months after the termination of this lease the tenants jointly and severally bind and oblige themselves to restore such land as may be injured by any of the several operations hereby authorised to an agricultural state, or pay to the First Parties or their foreaids, a sum at the rate of Thirty pounds Sterling per Imperial acre in lieu of such restoration; And likewise to repair all fences broken or injured by them to their former state and to leave all fences erected by them in a fencible and tenantable state of repair at the termination of this lease; And the tenants shall be bound within six months after the natural expiry or sooner termination of this lease, to remove the whole erections, machinery and apparatus and utensils connected with the working of the minerals hereby let so far as belonging to them unless the First Parties shall prior to three months before such termination intimate to the tenants their intention to take over all or any of these which the First Parties shall be entitled to do at a valuation to be made by two men of skill, one to be chosen by each party or by an oversman to be appointed by such valuators in case of their differing in opinion: Further in the event of the tenants becoming bankrupt or executing a Trust Deed for behoof of creditors or of their failure to pay the rent or lordships within six months after the same shall respectively become due then and in any of these cases this lease shall in the option of the First Parties be terminated and this may be declared by a writing under their hand or under the hand of the survivor of them or the hand of their Agent and shall be held as having terminated at the date of such writing and the same shall thereupon come to an end and be void and null without the necessity of any declarator or process of law to be used for that effect: And such nullity in the event of its declaration in writing as aforesaid shall not thereafter be purgeable by payment, any law or custom to the contrary notwithstanding: Reserving nevertheless full power to the First Parties to recover all arrears of rent or lordships due at the time or subsequently to become due and to insist upon the immediate fulfilment of all the obligations undertaken by and incumbent on the tenants in respect of their possession as at the natural expiry of this lease; And it shall be in the power of the First Parties or survivor if and when they shall have declared this lease to have terminated as above provided for, to enter into possession of the premises and to relet the said minerals or otherwise dispose of the same as they shall think proper in the same manner as if this lease had never been granted; And in such event the First Parties shall have the like optional right to take machinerey, utensils, &c., connected with the working of the minerals hereby let at a valuation as hereinbefore provided on the natural expiry or earlier termination of this lease; And both parties consent to registration hereof for preservation and execution. IN WITNESS WHEREOF these presents typed on this and the four preceding pages are subscribed by the said Mrs. Margaret Reid or Brown, William Wallace Brown, and the Star Coal Company - the signature being adhibited by Thomas Rutherford, one of the partners thereof - and also by William Annandale, Alexander Wishart, John Grierson, James Gourlay and the said Thomas Rutherford, all Miners, Star, Markinch, the individual partners of said Star Coal Company all at Star, Markinch on the seventeenth day of June Nineteen hundred and twenty two before these witnesses: James Thomson, Solicitor, Kirkcaldy and Mrs. Joan Maxwell or Brown, wife of the said William Wallace Brown.

(Sgd.) James Thomson, Witness (Sgd.) M. Brown
Joan Brown, Witness Wm. W. Brown
Wm. Annandale
A. Wishart
John Grierson
James Gourlay
Thomas Rutherford
The Star Coal Co.

Go Home