Benarty Pit and Mines, Blairadam

Owners: Lochore and Capledrae Cannel Coal Company (LCCCC)
Henry Ness Coal Company
Fife Coal Company (FCC)
National Coal Board (NCB)

Benarty Pit and Mines lay less than a mile to the north-east of Blairadam Bridge. Access was via Blairfordel by a small road which ran west to east eventually coming out at Lochore. A recent visit to the site revealed that access along this road to Lochore is now restricted.

Click on Map to Zoom In

The Benarty Nos. 1, 2 Mines appear to have been driven around 1880 by the LCCCC which had formed in 1835 and had embarked on a programme of sinkings to the east and west of Lochore. One Benarty Pit shaft is known to have been sunk around 1898 to a depth of around 73 fathoms, the shaft measuring 13 ft. x 5 ½ ft., at a location close to the mines, but deep shafts may have been sunk here at an earlier date.
Operating nearby (just to the north of the pit) was a small surface-mine believed to be Ness's Mine, owned by the Henry Ness Coal Company. Benarty Pit was taken over by the Fife Coal Company (FCC) in 1900 and closed in 1926 as a result of the collapse of the main winding shaft, the remaining coals continuing to be worked from the Aitken Pit.
It is believed that Ness's Mine closed around the same time as the pit but it unclear whether this mine had also been taken over by the FCC.


Mines opened ca 1880
Pit sunk ca 1898
Pit closed: 1926
Source Date of Information Supplied
Manager / Under-Manager / Men underground / Men above ground / Coal seams worked
1890 (LCCCC)
Nos. 1, 2 Mines: J. Ferguson / ------------ / 97 / 21 / Main Coal
No. 2 D'cast (10 x 6) 900 ft. : U'cast (10 x 6) 96 ft.  Fan ventilation at No. 1 Mine.
1893 (LCCCC)
J. Ferguson, manager.
1896 (LCCCC)
Duncan Ferguson / ------------ / 138 / 21 / Manufacturing and steam coals.
1898 (FCC)
March: Mr John Morrison, under-manager, leaves to fill a position in Lassodie Mill Colliery.
1899 (FCC)
Joseph Park / John Duncan / --- / --- / Manufacturing and steam coals.
1902 (FCC)
John Allan / ------------ / 121 / 18 / Manufacturing and steam coals.
1904 (FCC)
John Allan / ------------ / 132 / 25 / Manufacturing and steam coals.
1905 (FCC)
------------ / ------------ / 207 / 31
1908 (FCC)
Robert Love / James Erskine / 229 / 42
1909 (FCC)
Robert Love / William Kirkland / --- / ---
1910 (FCC)
March: Robert Love transferred to Kinnaird Colliery as manager.
1911 (FCC)
Mr George Christie, manager ?
J. Curley / James McDonald / 208 / 53
1912 (FCC)
Oct: Mr George Christie, manager, appointed manager of Cowdenbeath No. 10 Kirkford Pit
Nov: Mr James McDonald, appointed colliery manager.
James Paterson appointed under-manager (ex-Mary Colliery, Lochore)
1917 (Fife Coal Co. Ltd.)
Jul: Mr James McDonald appointed manager at Mossbeath Colliery.
1918 (FCC)
W. G. Spalding / James Paterson / 87 / 27
1920 (FCC)
W. G. Spalding / James Paterson / 174 / 51
1921 (FCC)
Oct: Mr James Paterson appointed under-manager at No. 2 Pit, Valleyfield Colliery.

---------------------------------------------------

Plans of Abandoned Seams for Benarty Pits or Mines designated in Plans
COAL; Kinglassie Splint (1887); Main (1888); Lower Jersey (1895); Bank (1900); Five Feet (1905); Jersey; Cairncubie; Rough; Little BENARTY:
Ness
COAL; Main; Top; Bank; Coal above Bank; Kinglassie Splint (December, 1900) BENARTY:
Ness
COAL; Glassee (April, 1920); Dunfermline Splint (September, 1920); Five Feet (October, 1921) BENARTY
COAL; Upper Bank; Lower Bank; Kinglassie Splint (December, 1924) BENARTY

------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Saturday Press"
30 November, 1889
NEW COAL-FIELD NEAR LOCHORE

The Lochore and Capledrae Cannel Coal Company have struck a seam of coal of excellent quality, over six feet thick, in their new mine on Benarty estate, which adjoins Lochore. Besides this seam of coal, there are within about 30 feet other two good seams - one 3 feet thick and the other 5 feet thick. A large output will be got at once.

------------------------------------

"The Scotsman"
1 March, 1890
FOR SALE.

I. The Compact ESTATE of LOCHORE, situated in the PARISH of BALLINGRY and COUNTY of FIFE. ...
A Branch of the North British Railway passes along the South Boundary, and a Railway Siding belonging to the Property gives the Estate all the advantages of railway accommodation.
It is believed the Lochgelly series of Minerals exists throughout half of the Lands, and can be worked without material interference with the amenity of the Estate. Recently bores, &c., have been put down with the view of proving this, and journals of these bores can be inspected. Reporting, thereon, the late Mr J. R. Williamson, M.E., estimated the workable coal in Lochore (exclusive of Cannel) at 16,000,000 tons. The Seams have not been opened up in Lochore, but some of them have been opened up in Benarty Colliery, which is situated immediately on the west. The Seam known as the Capledrae Cannel Coal Seam is believed to exist over 80 acres of the Lands. There are also other Seams of Cannel and Ironstone.

II. The TENANTS PART of a LEASE of the COALS, &c., in the LANDS of BENARTY, adjoining Lochore Estate on the west, together with the whole Plant and Fittings connected with two Mines presently being worked. Duration, 31 years from Whitsunday 1888, with breaks in favour of tenants. The output at present is about 150 tons a day, which could be largely increased as the Seams are further opened out. - Under the Lease Mines in Lochore may be connected with Mines in Benarty. Mr Williamson estimated the quantity of workable Coal in Benarty at 5,000,000 tons. ...

A Lithographic Plan of the various Estates, with a memorandum giving further particulars, and Orders to see the Property, may be obtained from Mr RICHARD BROWN, C.A., 28 St Andrew Square, Edinburgh, Liquidator of the Lochore and Capledrae Cannel Coal Company, Limited; or Messrs DRUMMOND, & REID, S.S.C., 21 Charlotte Square, Edinburgh, the latter of whom have the Titles.
Offers for the whole or any part to be lodged with Mr RICHARD BROWN, before 31st March 1890.

------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Saturday Press"
8 August, 1891

John Finlayson, a stoker and guard in connection with Blairadam Colliery, met with an accident, which terminated fatally, while engaged in shunting operations early on Monday morning. He had been attempting to sprag a waggon with a pit prop, which it appears had been too long for the purpose, and the result was that he was thrown in front of the waggon and the wheels passed over his left leg below the knee.
Finlayson was conveyed to the Edinburgh Royal Infirmary, where it was found necessary to amputate the injured limb. The unfortunate lad succumbed to his injuries the same evening. He was 18 years of age, and was the son of a ploughman at Benarty Farm.

------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Saturday Press"
26 December, 1891

While Robert Spittal, miner, Oakfield, was, on Thursday last week, working at the coal face in Benarty coal pit, belonging to the Capledrae Coal Company, a mass of coal fell from the roof upon him, causing the handle of his pick to penetrate the abdomen. Spittal died while being conveyed home.

------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Saturday Press"
25 November, 1893

Arthur Fairfield, miner, Lochore, met with an accident on Tuesday while working at the wheel brae at Benarty Coal Pit, belonging to the Lochore and Capledrae Cannel Coal Company. A hutch, laden with pit props, had accidentally come in contact with the roof, knocking out one of the props, which struck Fairfield in the right eye, inflicting rather serious injuries. Fairfield was attended by Dr Drysdale, Lochgelly.

------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Saturday Press"
25 May, 1895

John McLaren, Shields Farm, received injuries to his spine while working in Benarty Mine on Monday. He was attended by Dr. Dendle, who ordered his removal to Edinburgh Royal Infirmary.

------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Saturday Press"
25 April, 1896

Alexander Graham, miner, Lochore, had a narrow escape on Wednesday while engaged at a wheel brae in the underground workings of the Benarty Mine, belonging to the Lochore and Capledrae Cannel Coal Company. He was spragging an empty hutch to allow a full one to pass. The back wheels of the empty vehicle went off the rails, and knocked out a pit prop which was supporting the roof. There was at once a serious fall - the quantity which came away weighing eight tons. Graham was buried underneath the fallen debris. He was extricated as soon as possible, and conveyed home, where he was attended by Dr Dewar, assistant to Dr Dendle, Lochgelly. Graham was severely bruised, but, luckily for him, he was not otherwise injured.

------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Saturday Press"
21 August, 1897
BALLINGRY - PRESENTATION

On Saturday evening, a very interesting function took place in the Public School. The workmen in connection with the Lochore and Benarty Collieries, taking into consideration the friendly feeling which exists between Mr Duncan Ferguson, the manager of the works, and the employees, resolved to give expression to their sentiment of goodwill, by presenting him with a handsome dining-room timepiece, and a silver water jug for Mrs Ferguson. The chair was occupied by Mr John Morrison, underground manager. Mr D. McGalloway made the presentation. Mr Ferguson thanked the workmen for their handsome gifts, and hoped that the friendly feeling now existing between them might long continue.

------------------------------------

"Cowdenbeath & Lochgelly Times"
2 March, 1898

Last week the workmen of Benarty waited upon Mr John Morrison, their under-manager, to do honour to him on the occasion of his leaving Benarty to fill a similar position in Lassodie Mill Colliery. ...

------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
27 May, 1899

EXPLOSION OF FIRE-DAMP AT BENARTY PIT
TWO LIVES LOST, AND A THIRD MAN INJURED

An explosion of fire-damp occurred at the Benarty Pit, belonging to the Lochore and Capledrae Cannel Coal Company on Monday morning., by which two men lost their lives and a third man was seriously injured. The pit is situated at the south-west base of the Benarty Hill on the borders of the counties of Fife and Kinross. Curiously enough, the shaft of the pit is in the Kinross county while the underground workings are in Fifeshire. The shaft was sunk about a year ago close to the mouth of a day mine which has been worked for a number of years. As yet the shaft has only been sunk to the five-feet seam, fifty fathoms or so below the surface. There is only one outlet, and consequently the number of miners employed at one time is limited to twenty. In order to make up for this restriction three shifts are worked in the 24 hours. While the shaft at present has no connection with the mine, several men have been employed for some time in the work of running a headway to the outcrop with a view to providing a second outlet, and so enabling the Company to increase the number of men employed at the pit.
The last shift of the miners engaged in the pit where the explosion occurred ceased work at two o'clock on Saturday afternoon, and there is no coal-getting between that time and six o'clock on Monday morning. One or two men, however, are usually employed on Sunday night repairing the roads and seeing that all is made right for the miners on Monday. Accordingly, at ten o'clock on Sunday night, two men - Joseph Hamilton, Kelty; and Michael Casey, Lochore - descended the shaft for the purpose of doing repairing work. In the natural order of things they would have stopped work at six o'clock on Monday morning. Half-an-hour before that time they were joined by James Morton, the fireman or pit inspector, who was making his inspection of the working places previous to the miners beginning the first shift. Morton had been down the pit previously, and in the interval was inspecting the day mine.
When Morton went down the pit at half-past five in the morning Hamilton and Casey were laying plates on a brae leading to what is known as a heading. These headings strike off the main or level road at different points. In the course of the operations Michael Casey had occasion to go to the top of the heading for a plate. It cannot be definitely ascertained whether he was carrying a naked light. In the majority of Fifeshire pits the workings are so damp that explosive gas is seldom if ever heard of, and the air-courses are now so much improved that black-damp, the enemy of the old Fife miner, never makes its appearance. Fire-damp being such a rare thing in Fife, the Davy or safety lamps are scarcely ever used, and it is quite customary for the miners to work with naked lights at all the pits in the county. It seems, however, that fire-damp has occasionally made its presence felt at the Benarty Pit, although not in such quantities as to make the use of the safety lamp absolute in all departments of the workings. A safety lamp was, of course, in use for inspecting the workings, because if there is any chance of explosive gas accumulating, it is natural to expect the accumulation to take place on the Sunday when work is at a stand-still, and the air is not disturbed by the ordinary mining operations that go on night and day throughout the week. Hamilton and Casey, when they descended the shaft on Sunday night, were provided with safety lamps as well as the inspector.
The men had also naked lights - it being understood that these should be used when they had satisfied themselves that there was no fire-damp in any of the working places. The men, it is understood, were working at the plates with naked lights, and when Casey set out for the top of the heading, Morton, it is stated, shouted to him not to go in case of an accumulation of gas. Casey is said to have replied that it was all right, as he had been there before during the night. Casey had no sooner reached the top of the heading than an explosion of fire-damp occurred. Hamilton was killed outright, and Casey sustained such injuries that he died within twenty-four hours afterwards. Morton was also very seriously injured.
It is somewhat remarkable that the man who lost his life instantaneously was at least ten yards distant from the actual scene of the explosion.
Hamilton's body showed comparatively little indications of burning, for although his moustache and the hair of his head were singed, the burning injuries in themselves were not sufficient to account for his death. Neither were there any marks of bruises on his body such as might have been caused by his being blown against the coal face through the force of the explosion. It was noticeable that one side of the unfortunate man's body was quite soft, and practical men who have worked in gaseous mines are of opinion that death must have been caused by the fitting up of the vacuum created by the explosion, the pressure that would thus be brought upon Hamilton being calculated at about fifteen tons. Immediately after the explosion Hamilton was heard giving a groan, and after that he showed no signs of life.
When the explosion took place, Casey and Morton were knocked down and stunned, but so far recovered as to realise that they might encounter choke-damp and that it was necessary to beat as hasty a retreat as possible. The two men were in total darkness - the explosion having extinguished their lights - and their experience must have been a terrible one, suffering as they were, not only from painful injuries, but from the shock which they had sustained. Both Casey and Morton spoke to Hamilton but received no answer, and they concluded that he was dead. At all events, they felt themselves powerless to render him any assistance, and the two started, as they thought, for the bottom of the shaft. As is said to be almost invariably the case in circumstances of the kind, the men took the wrong turn when they reached the level, and crawling on their hands and knees they went from the pit bottom instead of towards it, only discovering their mistake when they stumbled upon some miners' working tools. Setting their faces in a opposite direction they commenced to crawl along the road again. Morton did not get very far, for when the explosion occurred he had his right thigh fractured by the fall.
Badly as Casey was burned, he struggled on to the bottom of the shaft and signalled to the engineman at the pithead to start the winding-engine and take him to the surface. The usual signal is three "chaps" of the hammer, but the injured man was in such a frenzied state that he struck the hammer so often that the engineman could make nothing of it. At length Casey gave three distinct taps and the engineman brought the cage up to the surface. It being now near six o'clock in the morning, some of the miners had arrived to begin their day's work. When the cage appeared at the pithead a horrible sight met their gaze.
Casey was leaning against the iron bars with his burned and blistered arms and hands drooping at his side. His shirt was almost completely burned off his body, and his back and chest, arms, hands, face, and neck were scorched to such an extent that in the words of one of the eye-witnesses, "the skin was fair peeling off him." The poor man was actually tearing the skin from his hands and arms. The pain was, of course, intensified by the exposure to the air, and, as soon as possible, Casey was removed to the engine-house, where appliances are kept for accident cases. Oil was poured upon him, his sores covered up, and the miners did all they could to alleviate the man's sufferings until the arrival of Dr Dickson, Lochgelly.
Casey showed as much concern for the safety of Morton as for his own injuries. He expressed the belief that Hamilton had been killed on the spot. He urged the men to descend the shaft and rescue Morton from his perilous position. A rescue party was accordingly organised without delay. Morton, as already said, was well aware that an explosion of fire-damp is succeeded by after-damp, and, despite his fractured thigh, he had struggled determinedly as far on towards the bottom of the shaft as he could. On Morton being discovered, he, like Casey, stated that he thought Hamilton was dead, but several men, headed by John Duncan, the oversman, made a gallant effort to reach the scene of the explosion. Twice they were beaten back by the after-damp, but on the third occasion they succeeded, only to find, however, that the fears of Casey and Morton were too well founded. The party next turned their attention to Morton. They put him in a hutch and raised him to the pit mouth. In addition to his having a fractured thigh, his face and hands were burned. What saved him from further burns was that his back and chest were well protected by two heavy shirts, securely buttoned both at the neck and wrists.
After Morton had been taken to the pithead, Hamilton's body was brought up the shaft and removed to Miller's Buildings, Kelty, where deceased lodged. Hamilton was forty-four years of age. He belonged to the Motherwell district, and had only started at the Benarty Pit a week ago. He was married, and leaves a widow and a family.
Morton, who is forty-one years of age, was taken to his home at Lochore.
It was deemed advisable to remove Casey to the Dunfermline Cottage Hospital. His injuries were of such a serious nature that on his arrival at the hospital little hope was entertained of his recovery. The unfortunate man succumbed to his injuries at four o'clock the following morning. Casey was forty years of age.
The miners employed at the pit wonder how Casey managed to find his way to the pit bottom considering his injuries. He must have travelled two or three hundred yards.
It is also regarded as miraculous that Morton should have been able to crawl a hundred yards or so with a fractured thigh.
In consequence of the accident, work was suspended at the pit on Tuesday. Fire-damp explosions are almost unknown at the Fife pits, although only recently there was a slight explosion at Rosewell by which one man was injured.

------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
15 July, 1899

On Tuesday, James Stranners or Stenhouse, a young miner, residing at Hynd's, Lochore, was injured in the underground workings of the Benarty Colliery, Lochore and Capledrae Cannel Coal Company. A quantity of redd fell from the roof upon him, and while he was extricating himself he twisted his left leg, dislocating the bones at the haunch joint.

------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
29 July, 1899

This issue contains the full report of the Fatal Accident Inquiry into the deaths of Joseph Hamilton and Michael Casey at Benarty Pit on 23 May, 1899. Among those giving evidence included:- Joseph Park, colliery manager; James Morton, fireman; James Turner, engine keeper, Oakfield, Kelty; John Duncan, underground manager, Lochore; Allan Wotherspoon, miner; and George Kerr, fireman. The Jury returned a formal verdict.

Interestingly, some details on the pit emerged during the evidence given e.g. the shaft depth was given as 73 fathoms 4 feet; the shaft measured 13 ft. x 5½ ft.; the pit, at the five feet seam, was ventilated by a forcing fan - a fan placed at the downcast section of the partitioned shaft for forcing air down; the Bank seam, which was 40 fathoms down, had communication with another fan in the mine - the exhaust fan, whereas the first mentioned was a forcing fan.

------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
23 September, 1899

Cornelius Duffy, 26 years of age, miner or miner's labourer, residing at Dandy Row, Lochore, met with an accident on Thursday, which terminated fatally. Duffy was employed at the main pit of Benarty Colliery, wrought by the Lochore and Capledrae Cannel Coal Company. While a hutch of coal was being sent down the wheel brae the chain broke, and the run-away hutch dashed against Duffy, who was at the foot of the brae. The injured man was attended by Dr Dickson, Lochgelly, who ordered his removal to the Dunfermline Cottage Hospital. Duffy died in the Hospital within half an hour after admission.

-----------------

"Dunfermline Press"
21 October, 1899

This issue carried the Report of the Fatal Accident Inquiry into the death of Cornelius Duffy, miner, Lochore, who was fatally injured at Benarty on 21st September. Among those giving evidence were Duncan Ferguson, manager; John Duncan, colliery oversman, Lochore; James Morris, miner, Lochore; and James Lyle, pit inspector. The Jury found that deceased was fatally injured by a hutch coming against him in consequence of the breaking of a chain.

-----------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
1 September, 1900
FIRE AT A FIFE PITHEAD

Last Saturday night fire was discovered to have broken out at the pithead of the Benarty Pit, belonging to the Lochore and Capledrae Cannel Coal Company. It may be remembered that it was at this pit that a fire-damp explosion resulting in the death of two men occurred eighteen months ago. The pit is situated at the foot of Benarty Hill and stands on the borders of the counties of Fife and Kinross. Curiously enough the pithead is in Kinross-shire, while the underground workings run into Fife. The fire on Saturday night was discovered at eleven o'clock. Work was suspended at the pit at two o'clock in the afternoon, and in consequence of the fact that Lochore Games were held on Saturday, the only men at the pit in the afternoon were two enginemen and two firemen in charge of the pumping engine. The outbreak of fire occurred in the pitheadman's box on the top of the platform scaffolding. The enginemen and firemen lost no time in starting to the work of extinguishing the flames. There are two sets of fire hose at the pithead, and there being a good supply of water the fire was soon under control. One or two railwaymen and others were attracted by the flames and they lent valuable assistance. The manager of the pit, who resides at Lochore House, was sent for, but before he had time to arrive, all danger, fortunately, was past. There is no doubt that but for the prompt measures taken to cope with the outbreak, the fire would have assumed alarming proportions.
The whole of the roofing above the scaffolding was destroyed, and a portion of the platform floor was also burned. The shear-legs, which support the winding gear, had also become ignited, and had the fire not been so promptly discovered and so smartly dealt with a good deal of damage would have been done to the shaft. Work at the pit was not in any way interfered with by the fire. The scaffolding has been renewed during the course of the week. It is expected that from £70 to £100 will cover the damage done.

-----------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
1 September, 1900
FIRE AT A FIFE PITHEAD

Last Saturday night fire was discovered to have broken out at the pithead of the Benarty Pit, belonging to the Lochore and Capledrae Cannel Coal Company. It may be remembered that it was at this pit that a fire-damp explosion resulting in the death of two men occurred eighteen months ago. The pit is situated at the foot of Benarty

-----------------------------------------------


"Dunfermline Press"
8 December, 1900

On Thursday morning, Robert Harrower, contracting drawer, Lochgelly, was knocked down by a race of run-away hutches in the underground workings of the Benarty Pit, Fife Coal Company. Two of Harrower's ribs were broken.

----------

"Dunfermline Press"
22 December, 1900
FATAL RESULT OF AN ACCIDENT

Robert Harrower, forty years of age, contractor drawer, who, as previously reported, was injured in the Benarty Pit, Fife Coal Company, on 6th inst., succumbed to his injuries on the 10th inst. In the Dunfermline Cottage Hospital. Harrower had been knocked down by a race of run-away hutches, and several of his ribs were broken.

-----------

"Dunfermline Press"
12 January, 1901

This issue carried the Report of the Fatal Accident Inquiry held at Dunfermline Sheriff Court yesterday into the death of Robert Harrower, drawer, Lochore, who was fatally injured in No. 1 Pit, Benarty Colliery, through being struck by some hutches which had run away owing to the breaking of a coupling chain. A formal verdict was returned.

-------------

"Dunfermline Press"
8 June, 1901
£350 DAMAGES

In Dunfermline Sheriff Court on Tuesday, settlement was intimated of an action at the instance of Mrs Margaret Ramsay or Harrower, residing at Lochore, Ballingry, widow of Robert Harrower, contractor drawer, Lochore, against the Fife Coal Company. ... The case has now been settled, the defenders having paid the sum of £350 and expenses.

------------------------------------------------

"The Scotsman"
18 February, 1902

BLASTING ACCIDENT IN A FIFE PIT. - Frank Fotheringham, miner, Oakfield, Kelty, was seriously injured yesterday in the Fife Coal Company's Benarty Pit. He had prepared a shot and retired, and as the explosion did not occur at the time expected he went forward to his working face, when the shot went off, and he was badly burned about the face and other parts of the body.

------------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
22 February, 1902

While engaged in blasting operations on Monday at Benarty Pit, Peter Fotheringham, a young miner, residing at Oakfield, sustained a rather serious injury. A shot of gelatine having "hung fire", he returned in order to ascertain what had gone wrong, when the shot exploded, with the result that he was badly injured about the face and upper parts of the body by the debris which was thrown about. The injured man was conveyed home with all speed, and attended by a doctor.

------------------------------------------------


"Dunfermline Press"
26 April, 1902
EXPLOSION IN BENARTY PIT

Fire-damp has again made its presence felt, with fatal result, in the Fife Coal Company's Benarty Pit. Thomas McIntosh and John Neally, both miners, residing in Kelty, were engaged on Saturday in putting up a prop in the five-feet seam, when a quantity of gas ignited, and both men were severely burned about the face, shoulders, and arms. McIntosh, who was more seriously injured than Neally, was removed to the Dunfermline Cottage Hospital, where he died the following day. The deceased was forty years of age. Nearly three years ago, two men met with their death by an explosion of fire-damp in the same pit.

--------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
3 May, 1902

This issue carried the Report of the Fatal Accident Inquiry into the death of Thomas McIntosh at Benarty Colliery last month. Among those giving evidence were:- John Allan, colliery manager; George Kerr, pit inspector; Robert Reid, miner, Kelty; John Neally, miner; and John Butters, oversman. The Jury returned a formal verdict.

--------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
9 July, 1904

John Finney, Kinross, and James Conway, Lochore, were seriously injured yesterday morning in the Benarty Pit, Lochgelly, belonging to the Fife Coal Company. They had been riding on a hutch, when a connecting chain broke. Both were crushed against the wall. Conway had his jaw and arm broken and his head badly cut, while Finney was injured internally. They were unconscious for four hours, and were removed to the Dunfermline Cottage Hospital. On inquiry at the Hospital last night, it was ascertained that the condition of both men is regarded as critical, both having been very seriously injured

--------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
8 July, 1905

On Thursday, Mr Thomas Liddell, 14 Grievesland Terrace, Kelty, had two of his ribs fractured in Benarty Pit. After being attended to he was removed home.

--------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
30 December, 1905

At about eight o'clock on Monday morning, David Flockhart, miner, Gladstone Terrace, Kinross, sustained a fracture of the left leg while working at Benarty Colliery. A fall from the side of the road had taken place.

--------------------------------------------


"Dunfermline Press"
17 February, 1906

Under the Fatal Accidents Inquiry Act, an inquiry was held in the Sheriff Court, Dunfermline, on Thursday - before Sheriff Shennan and a Jury - into the circumstances attending the death of a miner named David Flockhart, who was killed in Benarty pit by a fall of material from the roadway on 18th December. Those giving evidence included Police Constable William Mitchell, Dunfermline; Murray Todd, drawer, Kinross; John Allan, manager; Bernard McCabe, drawer, School Wynd, Kinross; Henry Davidson, pit inspector, Front Rows, Lochore; and Dr Tuke, Dunfermline and West Fife Hospital. On the suggestion of the Sheriff, the verdict of the Jury was to the effect that there was no evidence to say whether the death was the result of the injuries or not.

---------------------------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
27 April, 1907

William Duff, miner, 20 Grievesland Terrace, Kelty, met with a serious accident while employed at Benarty Colliery on Sunday. A large quantity of material came away from the roof, breaking his right leg, and causing severe injuries to his head.

---------------------------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
4 May, 1907

George Kinloch, miner, Kinnaird Cottages, Kelty, was severely burned about the hands and face while at work in Benarty Colliery on Thursday forenoon by an explosion of gas. He was conveyed to Dunfermline and West Fife Hospital. ...

---------------------------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
15 June, 1907

Under the Fatal Accidents Inquiry Act, an inquiry was held in the Sheriff Court, Dunfermline, on Thursday - before Sheriff Shennan and a Jury - into the circumstances attending the death of a miner named Michael Thomson, lately residing at Bellevue Place, Kelty, who according to the petition, "received injuries to his head on 28th December 1906, in 'an end' in Ballingry, connecting No. 8 level and No. 10 level in Benarty Colliery, by losing his balance in, and consequently slipping down said end, and died on 24th April, from the effects of said injuries."
Among those giving evidence at the inquiry were: William Duff, pit fireman, 20 Grievesland Terrace, Kelty; John Rollo, miner, Brewery Buildings, Upper Oakfield; John Allan, colliery manager, Lochore; and Dr Carment, Kelty. The jury returned an open verdict, but, on the Sheriff's direction added the words - "But there is no evidence to show whether the death resulted from the effect of the said injuries."

---------------------------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
23 November, 1907

On Wednesday morning, Robert Mackie, miner, Lochore, had his thigh broken while at work in Benarty Pit. On the evening of the same day Neil McLean, miner, Milnathort, at the same pit, had his thigh severely lacerated and one of his arms bruised. Both men were removed to Dunfermline and West Fife Hospital.

---------------------------------------------------------------

H. M. Inspector of Mines Report 1907
Mr. Robert McLaren's Report

Fatal Accident at Benarty, Fife
Owner: Fife Coal Co., Ltd.
28 December, 1906

Michael Thomson, 38, Miner. A brae wheel was fixed and when it was put into operation it stuck, deceased went to release it and met with an accident. He died on 24th April, 1907.

------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
24 October, 1908
DOUBLE PIT TRAGEDY AT KELTY
A PARKNEUK VICTIM

On Thursday afternoon while two miners, named Robert Mitchell, Rockfield, Kelty, and David Campbell, Parkneuk, Dunfermline, were engaged doing repairing work in Benarty Pit, belonging to the Fife Coal Company, a sudden burst came away from the roof and entirely entombed the two men. When first discovered the men were alive, but another fall came away, and, before they could be extricated the men had succumbed. The accident was discovered about five o'clock, and it was 8.30 before the men were brought to the surface. Drs Carment and Moir were down the pit ready to render assistance if required.

--------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
21 November, 1908

Under the Fatal Accidents Inquiry Act, an inquiry was held in the Sheriff Court, Dunfermline, on Thursday - before Sheriff Shennan and a Jury - into the circumstances attending the death of miner Robert McHarg Mitchell, lately residing at Rohan Cottages, Kelty, and David Campbell, miner, lately residing at Blackburn, Parkneuk, who were killed on 22 October in the Stop Dook section of the five feet seam of Benarty Colliery, by a quantity of material falling upon them from the roof.. Those giving evidence included:- Robert Love, colliery manager; William Burns, mining contractor; George Barrie, drawer, North Road, Cowdenbeath; John Thomson, pit fireman; and Robert Farmer, fireman. A formal verdict was returned.

------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
23 January, 1909

Joseph Neilson, miner, 4 Glenallan Street, Lochore, has died from the effects of injuries received on the 8th January. He was working in the five-feet seam of the Benarty Pit of the Fife Coal Company, and was proceeding down a wheel-brae, when his foot slipped and he fell. He injured his side, but his condition was not thought to be serious, and he was able to walk home. Dr Dickson, Lochgelly, it is understood, certifies death to be due to the accident.

-------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
30 January, 1909

Under the Fatal Accidents Inquiry Act, an inquiry was held in the Sheriff Court, Dunfermline, on Thursday - before Sheriff Shennan and a Jury - into the circumstances attending the death of a miner named Joseph Neilson, Glenallan Street, Lochore, injured on 8th January by falling on the rails in the Fife Coal Company's Benarty Pit, and who was said to have died on the 18th January from pneumonia, which supervened, as the result of the accident. Among those giving evidence at the inquiry were:- Alexander McLeod, a surveyor; Archibald Kirkland, miner, Rosewell Terrace, Lochore (worked alongside the deceased); Robert Love, colliery manager; and Dr Dickson, Lochgelly, colliery doctor. A formal verdict was returned.

-----------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
1 May, 1909

A miner named John Gulland (55), residing at Lochore Rows, was fatally injured on Monday morning at Benarty Pit. A chain snapped on a wheel brae, and a heavy waggon broke away. It gained impetus on a hill, and without warning crashed against Gulland. When picked up both his legs were found to be broken. Dr Todd was summoned, but Gulland died within thirty minutes of the accident. Deceased leaves a widow and family.

--------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
29 May, 1909

... The last inquiry was relative to the death of John Gulland, hanger-on, lately residing at Lochore Bridge, who was killed in the Benarty pit on 26 April by being struck with a loaded hutch which ran away, through the tail chain breaking. James Erskine, the under-manager, gave it as his opinion that the cause of the accident was the snapping of a safety or split link. After a number of witnesses had been examined, the jury returned a formal verdict.

-----------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
Saturday, 18 September, 1909

John Thomson, pit inspector, about forty years of age, and residing at Grievesland Terrace, Kelty, was fatally injured in Benarty Pit, Kelty, belonging to the Fife Coal Company, early on Monday morning. Thomson had been coming to the pit bottom to finish his shift and, as is customary with the inspectors, was riding on a tram, when one of the couplings broke and the race going back the brae brought away a fall from the roof, the unfortunate man being jammed between the hutches and the debris. When extricated, Thomson was alive, but expired shortly afterwards. Deceased leaves a widow and young family.

-----------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
25 September, 1909

Under the Fatal Accidents Inquiry Act, an inquiry was held in the Sheriff Court, Dunfermline, on Thursday - before Sheriff Shennan and a Jury - into the circumstances attending the death of John Whitehead, pony driver, 9 Sand Port, Kinross, who was killed on 30 July in the slope dook section of Benarty Colliery, by being crushed between the roof props and a hutch in a race of empty hutches being driven by a pony under his charge to a lye. Those giving evidence included:- Alexander McLeod, surveyor, gave it as his opinion that if deceased had been in his right place he could not have met with the accident. Police Constable Swan, Lochore, stated that, among the witnesses from whom he had obtained a statement was a man named Thomson, who had since killed himself. William Kirkland, the under manager, and other witnesses having been examined, the Jury returned a formal verdict.

-----------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
16 October, 1909

Under the Fatal Accidents Inquiry Act, an inquiry was held in the Sheriff Court, Dunfermline, on Thursday - before Sheriff Shennan and a Jury - into the circumstances attending the death of John Thomson, pit fireman, lately residing at Grievesland Terrace, Kelty, who was killed in No. 1 Pit, Benarty Colliery, by a race of hutches running away on which he was riding. Those giving evidence included:- Robert Love, manager; Henry Todd, Hyre Terrace, Kinross; George Simpson, haulage engineman; John Honeyman Fernie, chain runner; Frederick Donnellan, hanger on; Stewart Park, oversman; and John McGinnis, pit fireman. The jury returned an open verdict.

-----------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
12 March, 1910
COLLIERY MANAGER HONOURED

At a social meeting of the men employed at Benarty Colliery on Friday evening, Mr Robert Love, who has been transferred from the management of Benarty to that of Kinnaird Colliery, was presented with a roll-top writing desk, together with a gold brooch and gold-mounted umbrella for Mrs Love. Mr George Allan, sen., presided, and Mr Robert Stobie, section oversman, made the presentations. Both gentlemen eulogised Mr Love's qualifications, and spoke of the respect in which he had all along been held by those whose privilege it had been to serve under him. Mr Love suitably acknowledged the gifts. An enjoyable musical programme was performed during the evening.

-----------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
Saturday, 2 April, 1910

On Tuesday forenoon, a young man named Gilbert Flannigan (19), residing in Kinross, was fatally injured while at work in Benarty Pit, Kelty. A lipe from the roof had come away, and fell on the lad, fracturing his skull in two places.

lipe -- a small intrusion or irregularity in the joints of coal seam, the joints being usually glazed.

------------

"Dunfermline Journal"
Saturday, 16 April, 1910
Fatal Accident Inquiry
Remarkable Roof Fall at Benarty

The third inquiry was that into the circumstances attending the death of Gilbert Currie Flannigan, drawer, Kinross, who was killed on 30th March by a fall of stone from the roof of Benarty Pit.
David Low, chain runner, South Street, Milnathort, deponed that he was only two or three yards from Flannigan, and was in the act of greasing the wheels of a hutch, when suddenly a stone fell from the roof where Flannigan was. He called to Flannigan, who did not answer. He afterwards found Flannigan, with his face downwards, on the plates. Getting help, he lifted Flannigan out. He was then dead.
By Mr Pritchard - There was no motion in the roof before the accident.
By Mr Adamson - He did not observe, previous to the accident, that the stone was in a dangerous condition. That was his first day in that part of the pit, and he paid no attention to the stone.
Robert Stobie, sectional oversman, Grieve's Land Terrace, Kelty, said that the stone had fallen by reason of the fact that on one half of it there was a very keen lipe and on the other half there was something like a water break. Very little disturbance in the strata would cause a stone like that to drop out.
There was no possibility of supporting it under the circumstances of the place where it happened to be? - It could have been supported after it was seen if it had required support. There were no visible signs of a lipe when the stone fell. There was no support to it.
By Mr Adamson - You said it could have been supported after it had been observed that it was dangerous? - Yes; the stone was really supported on one of the ends. It broke over the bar on the top side. It is not true that a portion of this stone was taken away before the accident occurred.
Nothing had been done at that part? - No; the roof never was broken.
Had any of the stones been cut off in the vicinity of that one? - Yes; 6 feet below it.
Don't you think there should have been more cleading in? - No; I don't think so.
You think it is possible for a stone 6 feet long to drop between the bars where the cleadings are put in the proper way? - Yes; with a lipe like that.
Are you keeping in mind that the stone was 6 feet long? - Yes.
Do you think it is possible that a stone 6 feet long could get out in a properly clad place? - Yes.
Mr Adamson - I am sorry to say that I can't agree with you.
By Mr Kerr - The stone broke over the end of the cleading. The measurements of the stone were 6 feet by 13 inches by 13 inches.
By Mr Adamson - Don't you think that the fact that a fatal accident occurred there proved that the cleading was not sufficient? - It proved, Mr Adamson, that there are some things in mining which the cleverest men don't see.
Mr Adamson - I think this accident also proves that in practical mining every precaution should be taken to prevent that sort of thing occurring.
By Mr Kerr - You do that? - Yes.
William Clark, fireman, Bath Street, Kelty, deponed that if he had seen the least things wrong there he would have got it repaired.
By Mr Adamson - Was your attention drawn to the dangerous nature of the stone some time previously? - No; no complaint was made to me.
None of the drawers had directed your attention to the dangerous nature of this stone? - No.
Was no brushing done at that particular part several weeks before the accident? - No; there never was.
Was there sufficient cleading between the bars? - We expected there was.
Was there sufficient in your opinion? - Yes.
This finished the evidence.

------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
20 August, 1910

John Gainer, miner, Lochore, had his back severely crushed while at work in Benarty Pit, Kelty, on Monday. Gainer had been bending over a hutch when a fall from the roof took place. Dr Moir attended Gainer, who was removed to his home in the ambulance van.

------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
23 December, 1911

This issue reported that employees of Benarty Colliery held a social meeting in the Gothenburg Hall, Kelty, on Saturday evening and presented Mr R. McEwan, colliery electrician, with gifts on the occasion of his departure for Queensland. Mr McDonald, oversman, presided, and the presentation was made by Mr Wilson, winding engineman.

------------------------------------

"West Fife Echo"
Wednesday, 31 January, 1912
MINERS ENTOMBED AT BENARTY

On Thursday, three miners named James Smith, Kelty; John Sandilands, Kinross; and John Donaldson, Milnathort - were entombed for fourteen hours in Benarty Pit, belonging to the Fife Coal Company. The men were engaged on the nightshift, and were working in a place getting through to old workings. A sudden fall of material came away on both sides of where the men were at work, and completely caged them in. Assistance was at once forthcoming, and after a time communication was got with the entombed men, showing that all three were safe. The work of clearing away the debris from the Benarty Pit was a stupendous task, and latterly it was decided to organise a rescue party from the Aitken Pit which was at once done. The party set to work, under the guidance of Mr David Beveridge, colliery agent. After a hard spell of work, the men were released, and were brought up the Aitken Pit shaft. Altogether, the men were about eighteen hours down the pit, but were none the worse of their exciting experience.

--------------------------------------------------

"Cowdenbeath & Lochgelly Times"
10 July, 1912

Mr James Smith, miner, Kelty, was rather seriously injured while at work in Benarty Pit on Thursday. Smith had just finished charging a shot, and through some cause or other the charge exploded, and one of Smith's arms was so severely injured that on his removal to Dunfermline and West Fife Hospital, it was found necessary to amputate the arm below the elbow.

--------------------------------------------------

"Cowdenbeath & Lochgelly Times"
31 July, 1912

Martin Hainey (19), an underground worker, who resided with his parents at Arthur Place, Cowdenbeath, was killed instantaneously with a hutch running away on a steep incline in the Benarty Pit on Wednesday night.

----------------------------

"Cowdenbeath Mail"
3 August, 1912
THE BENARTY PIT FATALITY
TERRITORIALS ATTEND FUNERAL

The funeral of Martin Hainey, the young Cowdenbeath miner who met with a shocking death in Benarty Pit late on Wednesday night of last week, took place from his parent's residence in Arthur Place, to Beath Cemetery on Saturday afternoon. ...
[The remainder of the report details the ceremony at the graveside.]

----------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
7 September, 1912

Under the Fatal Accidents Inquiry Act, an inquiry was held in the Sheriff Court, Dunfermline, on Thursday - before Sheriff Umpherston and a Jury - into the circumstances attending the death of Martin Hainey, junior, miner, Marshall Street, Cowdenbeath, who was killed in Benarty Pit on 24 July while riding on a hutch in the splint dook. Those giving evidence included George Christie, the colliery manager.
After further evidence - in which it was stated that the officials occasionally rode on hutches - the jury returned a formal verdict.

----------------------------------------------

"Cowdenbeath & Lochgelly Times"
20 November, 1912

Mr James Paterson, who has been oversman in the Glassee and Mynheer sections of the Mary Pit for the past three years, has received the important appointment of under-manager at Benarty, and was met by a large number of his fellow-workers and friends on Saturday night in the Gothenburg Hall, Lochore.

----------------------------------------------

"Cowdenbeath & Lochgelly Times"
6 August, 1913

Mr Wm. Clark, inspector, Benarty Pit, and residing at 165 Waverley Street, Lochore, at the recent examination secured his second class certificate.

----------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
29 March, 1919

While at work in Benarty Colliery, Blairadam, on Wednesday, John Hynd, a stone miner, residing at Lower Oakfield, Kelty, was accidentally killed. Deceased, along with another workman, was attempting to remove a large stone from the roof of his working-place when it suddenly came away and fell on him. Deceased was about forty years of age, and leaves a widow and three young children.

----------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
9 July, 1921

... In the Kelty area, the men are faced with a serious state of affairs. There, only something like 6 per cent. of the pit workers have been absorbed. Blairenbathie and Benarty Pits have not so far been opened at all; and the conditions at other pits, in the way of damage by flooding and otherwise, is such that a long time must elapse before there is anything like a general resumption. Meantime, in all the areas where the pumping gear has been put out of action by flooding, strenuous efforts are being made to make good the damage, which, in many instances, has been found to involve the installation of new plant.

----------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
30 July, 1921

... Blairadam and Blairenbathie Collieries are gradually getting into motion again. Nothing has been done so far in Benarty Colliery, about one-fourth of the men being unemployed. The suffering is still very acute.

----------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
27 August, 1921

Work was resumed at Benarty Colliery on Monday, the first start since the coal trade dispute, and a few extra men are being engaged daily. The men employed at Blairadam and Blairenbathie are being hard hit, only working about two or three days per week. The Aitken and Lindsay Pits are working steadily, and the output is already far in excess of that secured for some years. Work is likely to be suspended for a day or two at the Lindsay Colliery, where the management have been forced to install heavier electrically-driven winding gear with a view to coping with the increased output.

----------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
8 October, 1921

... Mr James Paterson, who was formerly under-manager at the Fife Coal Company's colliery at Benarty, has been appointed to a similar position at No. 2 Pit, Low Valleyfield. Mr John Skimming has been appointed under-manager at No. 1 Pit. ...

----------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
10 March, 1923
KELTY COLLIERY CLOSED.
SUBSIDENCE OBSTRUCTS THE SHAFT.

Benarty Colliery, near Kelty, which employs over 100 men, will be closed for one month as the result of a ground subsidence. Over two hundred yards from the pit shaft there is the entrance to a "mine", a shaft sunk on an incline which has served as an outlet to the pit and an air course as well. About fifteen yards from the entrance to this "mine" the subsidence took place, completely closing the shaft. Before more than ten men can now be employed in the pit another outlet must be sunk, and as that is estimated to take a month the pit will be idle for that time. During that time work of repair will be carried on, which will absorb some of the unemployed, while already a number of men are engaged "filling off the bing", there being a reserve stock of three thousand tons laid down at the colliery. It is estimated that at least fifty men will have to find employment at other collieries.

----------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
21 April, 1923
DISMANTLING OF BENARTY COLLIERY.

Benarty Colliery, Kelty, which is owned by the Fife Coal Company, Limited, has ceased to wind coal, and dismantling operations have already begun. One of the engine-houses has been demolished, and plant and other gear are being taken down, preparatory to their being transferred elsewhere. The colliery formerly had an output of 200 tons per day, and has provided employment for a considerable number of workmen for a long period. No official statement has been made as to the cause of the stoppage of the colliery, but it is believed that it has not been a profitable concern owing to the class of coal produced. It is expected that all the workers will find employment in the other pits in the district belonging to the Company.

----------------------------------------------

Information on coals worked at, or near, Benarty Pit & Ness's Mine

(based on a report from 1934)

Two offshoots from the Ochil fault have been encountered in the workings at Benarty colliery; the larger, proved at Ness's Mine, had a downthrow to the south of about 23 fathoms.

To the east of Benarty Pit, the Dunfermline Splint Coal was on average 4 ft. 2 in. with a faky pavement and roof. Wee or Two Foot Coal here was 2 ft. 8 in. thick, and in two leaves with a blaes parting. Nothing is known of the character of the seam in the steeply inclined belt to the east of Benarty colliery, but it is likely that a thickness of not less than 2 ft. was maintained as far east as Lochore. The Five Foot Coal seam normally lay about 11 fathoms above the Dunfermline Splint and was described as a fair household and good steam coal. The Five Foot Coal at Benarty was exhausted by 1921 but records show that a 4 ft. 2 in. to 5 ft. thick coal with a sandy pavement and a roof of blaes was worked at the pit. Between Benarty and Lochore collieries, the coal was standing in 'stoops' which may yet be recovered.

At Moss Wood, Benarty, an underground bore cut the Jewel Coal in two leaves of 16 in. and 18 in. respectively, separated by 3 ft. of hard fakes with ironstone balls. Fine-grained sediments immediately overlying the Jewel Coal were succeeded by 13 or 14 fathoms of sandstone at Benarty colliery. A thin fireclay separated this sandstone from the Mynheer Coal whose western limit could be traced from Benarty Pit, east of the Lindsay Pits and through Cantsdam to the Kingseat Coalfield.

Sediments between the Mynheer and Glassee Coals varied from 6 to 12 fathoms but an unusual development of the sandstone underlying the Glassee seam was noted in the ground east of Benarty colliery. Throughout this area the Glassee Coal was a thick seam of fair quality and was generally overlain by blaes with ironstone ribs. Evidence is lacking as to the nature of the seam in the steep belt between Benarty and Lochore collieries but there is no reason to suppose that the development was below the average. On the contrary, there appeared to be a considerable increase in thickness towards the east.
Bank or Lochgelly Parrot Coal was normally a composite seam and had been worked here supplying a fair household coal. An old surface-mine (Ness's Mine?) driven in the Bank Coal a short distance north of Benarty Pit, proved 3 ft. 10 in. coal with an 8 in. stone rib. The Lochgelly Splint seam here was frequently too thin and variable for profitable working but a small area round the pit measuring 2 ft. 6 in. to 3 ft. thick was worked.

The Swallowdrum Coal was not recognised in the Benarty Coalfield but it may have been that this coal was included in the seam known as the 'Lower Jersey'.

The outcrop of the Jersey Coals could be traced with some accuracy from the Lassodie Mill Pits to Benarty surface-mine. Small areas of Jersey Coals were worked from the surface-mine out to the east and south.

The Lower Jersey Coal was 5 ft. to 6 ft. thick but of poor average quality, while the Upper Jersey Coal measured 3 ft.

The Kelty Main Coal, the highest member of the Main group of coals, lay from 1 to 9 fathoms above the Upper Jersey Coal. Its outcrop was present at The Den, Benarty, and at the mill dam at Blair Mill. A 10 fathom fault proved near Benarty House shifted the outcrop eastwards and it met the Ochil fault some hundreds of yards east of Cleikimin. At Benarty, where the Kelty Main Coal was extensively wrought between the mine and the River Ore, the following composition of the seam was proved:

Blaes 3 ft. 4 in.
COAL, burnt 10 in.
Stone 1 in.
COAL, burnt 1 ft. 9 in.
Stone 4 in.
COAL 5 ft. 2 in.
Blaes -

This section was above average in thickness, but was typical in showing the development of dirt bands and the rather frequent burning of the coal by thin whinstone intrusions in the seams known locally as 'jocks'. The Kelty Main was never a good household coal being rather soft and sometimes 'sooty' with variable partings.
Rough Coal and Little Splint Coal were encountered here as two distinct seams. The upper seam, containing 4 ft. of coal, was separated by several feet of fakes and fireclay from the lower seam which measured 2 ft. 2 in. Sometimes one thick composite seam represented both the Rough and Little Splint coals.
Between Oakfield and Benarty colliery, a 20 ft. olivine-basalt that had been quarried at the surface, lay a few fathoms above the Rough and Little Splint Coals.

-----------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
20 June, 1936
DEATH OF MR PHILIP HODGE.

The death took place in the Edinburgh Royal Infirmary on Wednesday of Mr Philip Hodge, who for many years had been actively associated with coal mining in the county, and latterly with the mining trade union movement.
A native of Kelty, Mr Hodge went to work in the pits as a boy. Studying the technology of mining, he was appointed oversman in the Fife Coal Company's Aitken Pit, Kelty, and he subsequently became manager of the old Benarty Colliery, and later of the Fife Coal Company's colliery at Bowhill. He was still in the prime of life when he gave up colliery managerial work to devote his whole attention to the business of the Fife, Clackmannan, and Kinross Miners' Union, of which he became one of the permanent officials, residing at Valleyfield. ...


-----------------------------------


BENARTY SURFACE MINE

At the end of World War II, when there was a shortage of coal, the FCC decided to increase output quickly by driving short surface mines into known areas of coal lying at relatively shallow depths.
A new Benarty Mine (consisting of a main and a companion mine) was driven on the same site as the old Benarty pit in 1937 and was one of several such short-life mines in this category. [See also Oakfield and Blairenbathie Mines.]

Click on Image to Zoom In

Benarty Mine was very successful having a productivity of three times the national average. (Because of the 'good money' to be made, Benarty miners were nicknamed the Klondykers or forty-niners).

Locomotives hauled the coal, in 2-ton drop-bottom mine cars, to the bottom of the mine then the cars were hauled to the surface by rope-haulage. The coal was loaded into 30 ton bunkers and transported by lorry to the nearby Aitken coal preparation plant.

Work on the 'new' Benarty Mine was started in late 1937 but was suspended during the war years. Production commenced in 1945; it was acquired by the NCB in 1947 and the mine, due to be closed in November, 1959, due to exhaustion of reserves, actually closed a few weeks earlier due to a fire in a main airway.

Mine opened: 1937/developed 1944 Mine closed: 1959
Source Date of Information Supplied
Manager / Under-Manager / Men underground / Men above ground / Coal seams worked
1945 (FCC)
Mr George Marshall / ------------ / 75 / 5 / Household and steam coals. Seven Feet.
1946 (FCC)
Aug: Mr G. Marshall, manager, appointed manager at Blairenbathie Mine.
Mr George Buchan, manager at Wellsgreen, appointed manager.
1947 (NCB)
G. Buchan / ------------ / 154 / 10 / Gas, household and industrial coals.
Annual output = 97,300 tons.
1948 (NCB)
G. Buchan / ------------ / 154 / 11 / Steam coal. Seven Feet.
1949 (NCB)
G. Buchan / ------------ / 140 / 9 / Steam coal. Seven Feet.
1950 (NCB)
G. Buchan / ------------ / 180 / 9 / Steam coal. Seven Feet and Main Coal.
1951 (NCB)
G. Buchan / ------------ / 210 / 10 / Steam coal. Seven Feet and Main Coal.
1952 (NCB)
G. Buchan / ------------ / 193 / 11 / Steam coal. Seven Feet and Main Coal.
1953/54/55/56 (NCB)
Robert Gibb / ------------ / 193 / 11 / Steam coal. Seven Feet and Main Coal.
1957 (NCB)
R. Gibb / ------------ / 219 / 14 / Steam coal. Jersey and Main.
1958 (NCB)
R. Gibb / ------------ / 225 / 12
Gas, industrial and steam coals. Jersey, Cardenden Smithy, and Kelty Main Coals.
1959 (NCB)
R. Gibb / ------------ / 203 / 13
Gas, household, industrial and steam coals. Jersey, Cardenden Smithy, and Kelty Main Coals.

---------------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
20 November, 1937
NEW SURFACE MINE AT KELTY.

Thirty men are being employed at a new surface mine which has been opened by the Fife Coal Company, Ltd., on the south side of Benarty, Kelty, and close to the site of the old Benarty Colliery, which was one of the earliest pits operated in the Kelty coalfield. The seam of coal in the new mine is eight feet thick, and is expected to provide work for a considerable number of years.

---------------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
4 December, 1937
KELTY MINING ACHIEVEMENTS.

Very interesting work has been carried out in this district by the Fife Coal Company, Ltd. A number of bores have been put down into old workings where a gob fire has been giving trouble, due to leakage into the present workings. Into the bore holes thousands of tons of sand have been pumped. This has been a very difficult task, but complete success has rewarded the efforts.
Along with this work, two mines had to be driven from the surface as outlets.
The mine at Benarty has been pushed on at high speed and a record cutting achieved. With a double entry to the surface, 358 yards have been cut in 48 days, giving an average cutting of 44¾ yards per week. The best week's cutting was 56 yards. The average gradient of the mine is 1 in 3½.
All this work was carried out under the personal supervision of Mr K. H. McNeill, agent, and Mr J. Archibald, manager, Aitken Colliery. The mine contractors were Messrs Myles Brothers.

---------------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
2 February, 1946
MINING DEVELOPMENTS IN WEST FIFE.
Fife Coal Co.'s Vast Programme.

The Government's policy of nationalisation of the mines has tended to dwarf in the public mind all other questions affecting the industry. Yet in Fife a vast programme of development and modernisation is being undertaken by the Fife Coal Company, Ltd., and will assure the continued pre-eminence of the county as one of the greatest coalfields in Britain.
A well-known figure in the Fife coal industry, in conversation with a Dunfermline Press representative this week, said nationalisation was not regarded as a bogey to the future of the industry in so far as development was concerned, and the present schemes, and probably even larger plans for the future, would be proceeded with as a normal and necessary job of work.
The necessity of such schemes is emphasised by the falling output and reduced manpower, etc., and, briefly speaking, the aim of all concerned with the industry is to discard all but the most modern methods - both on the surface and underground - in order that production may be raised to meet the requirements of the country for home needs ad foreign consumption; and, in general, the reconstruction of the industry aims at an output per manshift equal to approximately two tons, or almost double that obtained now. ...

BENARTY MINE.

The latest technique and mining machinery have been utilised in the design and lay-out of Benarty mine, in which development of coal commenced in the last year. In this project two dippings which had previously been driven in the seven feet coal from the outcrop are being used to develop an area of coal capable of producing 500 tons per day for a period of fifteen years.
Underground, the modern methods of mining are fully utilised, the transport being operated with a 43 inch rail gauge, and on the levels a battery haulage locomotive, the introduction of which into Scottish mines was made by the Fife Coal Company in their Lindsay Colliery, Kelty, some years ago, is used.
The main slope is equipped with a 250 h.p. direct rope haulage, which hauls a load of six 2-ton capacity drop-bottom cars. As a point of interest at a time when production figures for the British coalfields make such gloomy reading, it is noteworthy that during development the mine was estimated to yield three tons per man, and on full production five tons per man, surface and underground. ...

These are but a few of the many schemes which the Company is undertaking. At many collieries smaller operations have been successfully completed, but in all of them, whether large or small, all modernisation has been directed towards three phases of mining - transport, face mechanisation, and surface reconstruction.

---------------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
3 August, 1946
VISIT TO FIFE COLLIERIES.

Sir Walter Citrine, a member of the National Coal Board and recently appointed chairman of the Miners' Welfare Commission, accompanied by Lady Citrine, visited Cowdenbeath district on Monday.
They were met at the Fife Coal Company's Central Offices at Cowdenbeath by Mr C. A. Carlow and Dr William Reid.
After being shown over the Central Workshops, they paid a visit to the open-cast mine at Benarty and the Company's modern colliery at Comrie.
Sir Walter displayed a keen interest in the temporary pithead baths being erected at Benarty, and went underground at Comrie for a tour of inspection.
Lady Citrine made a tour of the surface installations at Comrie, and showed much interest in the many modern features which form part of the general scheme and layout of the colliery. ...

---------------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
28 September, 1946
BENARTY SURFACE MINE.

At a largely-attended meeting of the Mining Institute of Scotland, held in the Royal Technical College, Glasgow, on Saturday under the chairmanship of the president Mr A. M. Ritchie, Bothwell Collieries, Lanarkshire, interest centred round a paper contributed by Mr Henry R. King, Fife Coal Company, on "Benarty Mine: A New Development in Scottish Coal Mining."
Officials of the Fife Coal Company during visits to America had been impressed, Mr King explained, with the simplicity and effectiveness of many, small, shallow mines, and an examination of the plans of the Fife Coal Company's leaseholds revealed that many areas of coal were available at outcrops which could be speedily developed, and would yield outputs of from 400 to 500 tons per day for periods varying from five to twenty-five years. Arrangements were made to establish six such units, and Benarty Mine was the first of these to be scheduled.
The area used had already been opened up by two roadways driven to provide ventilation for working the neighbouring Aitken Colliery. It was also arranged that Aitken Colliery would prepare coal from the new mine at Benarty for the market. Considerable economies were thus achieved.
The drop-bottom car developed by the Fife Coal Company for use in the new mine was believed to be the first of its kind put into daily use in British mines.
The results achieved had not so far reached the estimated man-shift figures of from four to five tons but as Benarty Mine was further developed it should be possible of attainment. The estimated yearly output from the project was about 130,000 tons.
Mr A. H. Ritchie, the president of the Institute, in opening the discussion, said the project could not be regarded as an example for mining in general because there were not many such opportunities for attacking the outcrops of seams. Indeed, in many cases mining engineers would hesitate to attack the outcrops at all for fear of endangering by water the more permanent workings in adjacent collieries.

---------------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
12 October, 1946
BENARTY MINE.
ERECTION OF BATHS.

Workers at the Fife Coal Company's Benarty Mine, near Kelty, will shortly be able to enjoy the advantages of pit-head baths. Work is nearing completion on the building, which consists of pre-cast concrete frames and blocks, and will provide accommodation for one hundred and fifty men.
Steam heating units have been installed, and each man will be provided with two lockers - one for dirty clothes the other for clean wearing apparel. Similar baths have been introduced at the Thornton Mine, and are also in course of erection at Blairenbathie. The baths have been erected by the Fife Coal Company, Ltd.

---------------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
21 June, 1947
BENARTY COLLIERY RECORD

Benarty Colliery has kept up its 6-day weekly output since the introduction of the five-day week in the mines. Last week, a new record was set up by the employees at the colliery, when 62 cwts. per man per day was raised.

---------------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
29 November, 1947
BENARTY MINE OUTPUT SURPASSED.

The remarkable output total of 68.97 cwts per manshift which was achieved at the Benarty Surface Mine, near Kelty, was surpassed during the week ending 15th November by the Thornton Mine, where the output was 70.52 cwts per manshift. Benarty gives employment to 150 men, while at Thornton 86 men are employed.

---------------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
25 September, 1948
BENARTY MINE ACCIDENT

Archibald Porteous, 6 Milne Crescent, Cowdenbeath, was admitted in a critical condition to Bridge of Earn Hospital on Thursday. He was struck by a heavy fall from the roof of the section he was working in in the Benarty Mine.

---------------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
26 March, 1949
BENARTY COLLIERY'S SUCCESS
Awarded Safety Diploma
AREA'S MANSHIFT-PER-ACCIDENT RECORD

On the occasion of the presentation of a diploma to Benarty Colliery, in recognition of their having won the National Coal Board Area Safety League Championship for 1948, a complimentary dinner was held in Cowdenbeath Miners' Welfare Institute on Tuesday evening. The guests included Lord Balfour, Scottish Divisional chairman of the N.C.B., and three members of the Russian women's delegation, which has been making an industrial tour of this country. ...

---------------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
20 December, 1952
DEVELOPMENT OF DRIFT MINES
Production Soon at Torry

Benarty, Blairenbathie, and the Lady Helen surface drift mines in West Fife are making a considerable contribution to the four million tons of coal which are produced annually in the Scottish coalfield by this method of mining.
The working of shallow seams of coal is nothing new. It has been practised in one way or another for centuries. Today the mining engineer is applying modern ideas of development to an old problem to achieve highly successful results.
Benarty mine, which was planned by the Fife Coal Company, Ltd., has always been regarded as an excellent example of the modern surface drift mine, and if its average output per manshift, which has been given at various times as 50 cwts., is not by any means a record for the county, it is undoubtedly achieving noteworthy results.

MODERN LAY-OUT

Like Blairenbathie, Lady Helen - and two new mines which will come into production at Torry, near Dunfermline, and Dundonald No. 2 - Benarty is equipped with direct rope haulage and drop-bottom mine cars. This form of transport has proved highly successful in cutting down non-productive labour. The estimated average output per manshift of surface mines in the Scottish Division which are equipped with this modern type of transport is 46 cwts., or double the overall average for all collieries and mines in the Division.
"With this type of drift," Mr H. R. King, Production Director of the Scottish Divisional Board, recently remarked, "an overall output per manshift of over 50 cwts is not uncommon, while a few exceptional cases have yielded an overall output per manshift of over 70 cwts."
The surface lay-out adopted by the Division for these drift mines follows a fairly uniform pattern designed to cut costs and facilitate speedy erection. It is also possible to dismantle the plant and transfer it to a fresh site when the coal becomes exhausted.
There is no indication that Benarty is approaching the end of its life-time, but the new Dundonald mine will be a replacement for the Lady Helen mine, and it will be surprising if the rich surface seams in West Fife are not further tapped by new units.

CONTRIBUTION TO PRODUCTION

The value of the surface drift mine in the battle of production is the subject of a statement issued by the National Coal Board Scottish Division. It states:-
"In Scotland there are substantial reserves remaining to be worked between the surface and a depth of say 500 or 600 feet, the recovery of which has received special attention, in order to increase output in the short term pending the construction and development of the new deep sinkings. Fittings of the size and depth of Rothes, in Fife, for example, take at least ten years to construct, whereas a new surface drift mine may be developed and brought into full production in about two years, or sometimes less.
"At vesting date some 55 surface drifts, producing about one-and-three-quarter million tons annually, were taken over by the National Coal Board in Scotland; about eight of these have since been worked out. Over and above the 55, eight drifts started under private enterprise were classified as suitable for immediate attention in order to increase their efficiency and output. By the end of 1947 there were 15 new or reconstructed N.C.B. surface drift mines in operation. Encouraged by the high output returns obtained from these new modern surface drift units, the Divisional Board have initiated many more schemes of a similar type within the last few years, with the result that the number of new surface drifts now in full production is 30.
"Summarising the position, there are still 47 of the older drifts in operation, producing fully two million tons annually, plus 30 new drifts and eight reconstructed units with a combined output of nearly another two million tons, making an output in all of some four million tons per annum - equivalent to 17 per cent of the Division's entire output.
To the 38 new and reconstructed drifts now in production, there will shortly be added some 10 others which are under construction, while a further 10 new schemes are under investigation, making a total of 58 either in production, under construction, or at the planning stage.
"During the next few years, however, about a dozen of the existing drifts will exhaust their reserves, leaving the programme to be carried on with an effective total of approximately 46 drifts. While the present annual output of the new surface drift programme of 38 reconstructed and new units is about two million tons, it is estimated that in a few years' time the 46 effective modern drifts then available will be producing between 3¼ and 3½ million tons a year. The productivity of these modern surface drifts is very high, the average output per manshift being around 34 cwts."

DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME HAS BEEN SPEEDED UP

Development of the coal industry in Scotland is not in a markedly different position from that of the rest of the country, it was stated in a written Parliamentary answer which Mr W. Hamilton (Lab., West Fife) has received from Mr Lloyd (Minister of Fuel and Power).
Mr Hamilton had wanted to know to what extent capital development in the Scottish coal industry was keeping pace with the scheme outlined in "Plan for Coal," and what were the prospects for speeding up development in the next few years.
Mr Lloyd explained that the National Coal Board's capital expenditure had recently been below the level envisaged in "Plan for Coal."
The board were doing all in their power, however, to accelerate their programme and had made some improvement this year.

---------------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
9 February, 1957
Trapped for Seven Hours by Pit Fall
Man Fatally Injured : Two Others Rescued

A 21-year-old Ballingry miner was fatally injured on Tuesday and two others entombed for seven hours at Benarty Mine, near Kelty. The dead man is Robert R. Bett, 36 Park Street, Crosshill.
With David Graham, 32 North Drum Street, Kelty, and George Livingstone, 38 Malcolm Street, Ballingry, he was working in an isolated section of the pit when a large fall occurred. Bett was almost completely buried, but the two others managed to scramble to comparative safety to face a terrifying ordeal.
They were cut off, and three hours passed before the fall was discovered and rescue work started. Bett was conscious throughout the seven hours, and spoke to Livingstone and Graham.
The latter two shouted to their colleagues that they were uninjured, and the rescue work was concentrated on Bett. When he was partially uncovered, and N.C.B. medical officer, Dr McKinnon, administered morphia, but the miner, who was extensively crushed, died on the way to Bridge of Earn hospital. A short time later Graham and Livingstone were freed.
Livingstone, speaking to a reporter, said: "It was a nerve wracking ordeal. The section had been closed and three escape roads we might have used were blocked up. We tried to pull Bett clear but he was held tight by a girder and we had no tools. Without props there was a great danger of another fall which would have completely buried him."
Livingstone and Graham were left in darkness when their carbide lamps gave out. Livingstone added: "The roof kept cracking and occasional showers of rubble came down about us and it was a horrifying experience waiting for the final fall which could finish us off."

---------------------------------------------------

"Lochgelly Times"
6 June, 1957

Over 200 miners employed at Benarty Mine, near Kelty, who have been on strike since Tuesday, resulting in the loss of over 2000 tons of coal, decided unanimously at a meeting in Kelty, to remain on strike. The cause of the dispute, claimed the union, was that management had reversed the circuit of ventilation on to a conveyor belt in a section of the mine causing fumes which were going towards the men instead of away from them. The men said their action was on the grounds of safety.

---------------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
31 October, 1959
Kelty Mine Closure Affects 200

Benarty Mine, Kelty, closed this week because of heating in the main return airway. Approximately 200 men are affected by the closure, which came only a few weeks ahead of the scheduled closure in November under the national programme.
Yesterday, the N.C.B. headquarters at Cowdenbeath issued the following statement:- "Heating caused by spontaneous combustion occurred in the main return airway of Benarty Mine, Kelty. Cement induction was used to control the heating, but it was not entirely successful. Subsequently it was decided to seal off the affected area."
This statement added that a proportion of the redundant men will be re-employed at collieries west of Dunfermline.
The Dunfermline Press was informed later that men would be employed for some time at Benarty on salvage work.

---------------------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
21 November, 1959
Only 29 Benarty Men Will Be Redundant

Only 29 miners from Benarty Mine, near Kelty, instead of the 120 originally forecast, will become redundant as a result of the premature closure of the colliery due to a fire in the main airway.
"We have succeeded in getting the great majority of the 200 men at Benarty placed in other collieries," said Mr William McLean, N.U.M. agent in Fife.
"The largest quota has gone to Valleyfield, and more have been given work at Blairhall. Others have been absorbed in smaller contingents into other pits in the Central-West Fife area."
Regarding those who will be redundant, Mr McLean stated: "We do not anticipate that these men will be idle for long. They will be drafted into local pits as vacancies occur through natural wastage. We expect that most of them will have jobs again early in the New Year." They include surface, oncost, and production workers.

---------------------------------------------------

The site, to the south of the slopes of Benarty Hill, was extensively opencasted between 1989 and 1999 and the land is now reclaimed and landscaped. At the western end of the site, the scrub-covered bings of Kinnaird Pit and Blairfordel Mine remain and can be seen from the main road passing Blairfordel farmhouse. (Blairfordel bing was reduced during the war years to provide blaes for Blairadam brickworks). It was understood that both bings were to be incorporated in the reclamation phase.

---------------------------------------------------


Home