Cardenden No. 5 Pit

Lying between Cardenden Station and Cardenden Cottages, to the north-east of Denend Colliery, was the "Big Pit" or No. 5 (Engine) Pit of Cardenden Colliery which apparently was also known as 'Spion Kop'. It was sunk to a depth of around 285 ft. and was badly flooded in November, 1867, when water rushed in from the neighbouring, smaller No. 6 Pit (see newspaper reports below).
One source indicates that the Cardenden Smithy Coal was encountered in the shaft at 7 fathoms; the Lochgelly Splint and Parrot Coal seams at 47 fathoms.

[The Battle of Spion Kop took place in Natal in January 1900. The Boers beat the British on the hill top which was known as Spion Kop.]

Why was this Cardenden Pit given this name?

Click on Map or Aerial View to Zoom In

See Central Fife Index Entry 'Cardenden Pits & Mines' for more details

Pit opened: 1860s? Pit closed: 1900s?
Source Date of Information Supplied
Manager / Under-Manager / Men underground / Men above ground / Coal seams worked / Shaft Details
1873 (J. Goodall)
W. Arnot / -- / -- / Lochgelly Splint / D'cast (14 x 5) 285 ft. : U'cast (9 x 5)222 ft.
Furnace ventilation.
1874 (J. Goodall)
---------- / 31 / 7 / Lochgelly Splint / D'cast (14 x 5) 285 ft. : U'cast (9 x 5)222 ft.
Furnace ventilation.
1875 (J. Goodall)
J. Goodall / 37 / 8 / Lochgelly Splint / D'cast (14 x 5) 285 ft. : U'cast (9 x 5)222 ft.
Furnace ventilation.
1876 (J. Goodall)
J. Goodall / 31 / 9 / Lochgelly Splint / D'cast (11 x 5) 246 ft. : U'cast (15 x 5) 270 ft.
Furnace ventilation.
1877 (J. Goodall)
J. Goodall / 28 / 10 / Lochgelly Splint, 5' / D'cast --- ft. : U'cast (15 x 5) 270 ft.
Furnace ventilation.
1878 (J. Goodall)
J. Goodall / 26 / 9 / Duddy Davie / D'cast --- ft. : U'cast (14 x 5) 210 ft.
1 fatality recorded at this pit.
1879 (J. Goodall)
J. Goodall / 31 / 10 / Duddy Davie / D'cast (11 x 5) 204 ft. : U'cast (14 x 5) 210 ft.
Furnace ventilation.
1880 (J. Goodall)
J. Goodall / 20 / 12 / Duddy Davie / D'cast (11 x 5) 204 ft. : U'cast ---- ft.
Furnace ventilation.
1881 (J. Goodall)
J. Goodall / 13 / 3 / Duddy Davie / D'cast (11 x 5) 204 ft. : U'cast ---- ft.
Furnace ventilation.
1882 (J. Goodall)
Andrew Dunsire / 13 / 4 / Fourteen Feet / D'cast (11 x 5) 204 ft. : U'cast ---- ft.


Plans of Abandoned Seams for Cardenden No. 5 Pits or Mines designated in Plans
COAL; Fourteen Feet (1875); Duddie Davie (1879); Smithy (1908); Lochgelly Splint (1909) CARDENDEN
No. 5, No. 6, No. 7; Adam James, Cluny, Dean, George, Hyndloup, Jane
COAL; Duddie Davie (1904); Fourteen Feet (1905); Lochgelly Splint; Smithy (1909); Lochgelly Parrot. CARDENDEN
No. 5, No. 6, No. 7; Adam James, Dean, George, Hyndloup

-------------------------------------


"Dunfermline Saturday Press"
30 November, 1867
FATAL ACCIDENT AT CARDENDEN COLLIERY

On Thursday afternoon, eight men and a boy were working in No. 6 Pit, of the Cardenden Colliery, occupied by Mr. James Goodall, when, breaking in upon an old waste, a large volume of water suddenly burst through, and instantly overcame four of the eight men who were within its reach. The other four men and the boy were working higher up, beyond the reach of the water, and thus escaped.

The first intimation of the inundation to those outside the pit was conveyed by the noise of the water, which, breaking through with great force, and carrying everything before it, made a tremendous sound, rushing towards No. 5 Pit. The pitheadman, hearing the roar of the water, thought that one of the pumping pipes in the pit had burst, and instantly sent for the manager who was at the time in the Dean Pit. The manager immediately went down, and found the water up to the door-head, a depth of about five feet. Two men then descended, and observing one of the bodies, one went up, and having obtained assistance, exertions were made to recover the men in the pit. Soon they discovered two dead bodies - those of William Hunter and Pedam - and had them conveyed to bank.
The water having by this time somewhat subsided, the four men and boy, who, fortunately for them, were working higher up than their fellow-workmen, and thus beyond the reach of the water, with some little difficulty were enabled to reach the bottom of the shaft, and were taken to bank.
There now remained two in the pit, Patrick Kennedy and John Macuskar. The men continued their search, and found the body of Kennedy, but were unable to discover the other. Meanwhile, the water continued to rush into the pit adjoining - No. 5.
The men working in the pit made their escape by the outlet pit. Engines were instantly set to work to pump the water from No. 5; and last night the water was still running, though of course much abated, into No. 5, from the pit where the water broke out. Work is of course completely stopped in both pits, and it is expected that some days will elapse before all is got right. The utmost exertions were used to discover the body of Macuskar.
A number of men were employed during the whole of the night, continuing until about six o'clock last night, when the body was found and brought to bank. The bodies were severely bruised, and had some of the limbs broken. William Hunter and James Pedam were married; and the former leaves a wife and three children; the latter, a wife and two children. Kennedy and Macuskar were unmarried.
It was of course never suspected that water had accumulated in the waste; and we believe plans were left when Mr. Goodall became lessee to indicate what parts of the field had already been worked. We understand that no accident of a fatal nature has occurred in Cardenden Colliery for a number of years; and this unfortunate occurrence has caused considerable excitement in the immediate neighbourhood, and awakened a feeling of sympathy in the district.

-------------------------------------

"The Scotsman"
30 November, 1867
CARDENDEN - COAL-PIT FLOODED
FOUR MEN DROWNED.

Great excitement was caused here on Thursday evening, when it became known that one of the coal-pits in this neighbourhood, generally known as the 'Little Pit', had become flooded while the miners were at work. The sorrowful intelligence spread like wildfire, and proved too true. In prosecuting their labours, the miners had struck upon an old working full of water; and the stream that poured in upon them was so heavy that four of the men were unable to save themselves, and were drowned. The names, so far as we have heard them, are - Patrick Kennedy, unmarried; John McCasker, also unmarried; William Hunter, who was married, and has left a widow and three children; and a man belonging to Lochgelly, who was married, and has left a widow and two children. The water has also affected the workings of another pit in the neighbourhood. The miners have ceased working in the district.
Another correspondent gives the following details of the accident:- "The colliery at which the disaster occurred is the property of Mr James Goodall, coalmaster, and is situated near the Cardenden Railway Station. About four o'clock, while the miners in one of the pits, commonly called the 'Little Pit', were pursuing their avocation, they came upon an unknown waste or old working, of apparently great extent, and filled with water, which, without the men receiving the least warning, burst through upon them. Of the eight men in the pit at the time of the occurrence, four were employed at the facing which separated the pit from the old waste. The other four were working in a higher facing, and had consequently the advantage of the first rush of the flood into the pit. Meantime the water had gained access to a much larger pit immediately adjoining, and about 20 fathoms deeper, the occupants of which made an almost miraculous escape by means of another shaft. All exertions were concentrated with a view to saving the inmates of the ill-fated 'Little Pit', eight in number. On a clearance being made, two bodies were got dead, and the explorers succeeded shortly afterwards in reaching the next workings of the pit, where four of the sufferers were known to be at work when the water broke in. These four men were rescued alive, the water fortunately not having reached the higher excavations at which they were employed. A third dead body was next discovered and brought to the pit's mouth, but up till last night all exertions to recover the other missing man had proved futile. No doubt remains that he too has been drowned, and in all probability his body has been carried away by the force of the water into the larger pit adjoining. The property in connection with the pits has been much damaged, and in all probability the miners engaged in them will not be enabled to resume work for four or six weeks hence."

-------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Saturday Press"
7 December, 1867
THE COLLIERY ACCIDENT AT CARDENDEN

On Saturday, Her Majesty's Inspector of Mines for Scotland examined the pit in which the occurrence took place, and Mr. Morrison, one of the Procurators-Fiscal for Fifeshire, made a precognition of witnesses on Monday, with a view to arriving at the cause of the accident.
Every exertion has been made to clear the pits by pumping out the water. As the "Little Pit" discharged the greater part of its contents into the larger one adjoining - from which, it will be remembered, the workmen made a somewhat narrow escape - and which still remains quite flooded (as the water is now fifteen fathoms up the shaft) there is no likelihood that it will be emptied for some time to come.
A subscription is meantime about to be set on foot in behalf of the relatives of the four unfortunate men.


-------------------------------------

14 December, 1867
THE LATE MELANCHOLY ACCIDENT AT CARDENDEN COLLIERY

The circumstances attending the occurrence of this melancholy and disastrous accident, by means of which four miners lost their lives, have been investigated by Mr. Morrison, one of the Procurators-Fiscal for the county. The investigation will likely lead to further proceedings in a Court of Justice.
It will be remembered that the immediate cause of the accident was the water from a waste breaking a pit owned by Mr. James Goodall, and to this part of the catastrophe Mr. Morrison has chiefly directed his attention. Mr. Morrison has also precognosced witnesses, and the precognition will, we are informed, terminate as indicated. The Act of Parliament applicable to coal mines requires that in such cases particular precaution is necessary, such as boring, with a view to test the existence of a waster such as the one which caused the death of the unfortunate men.


-------------------------------------

8 February, 1868
CLEARING OF THE FLOODED "LITTLE PIT"

This pit, the scene of a distressing and fatal occurrence, which took place on the 28th November last, as many of our readers will remember, and whereby four men lost their lives, has, after much continuous exertions, been cleared of the superabundant water, and will soon again be in working order.


The "Dunfermline Saturday Press" of 18 April, 1868, carried a report indicating that Mr. James Goodall, manager of Cardenden Colliery, and his underground manager, Mr. Andrew Wallace, were found not guilty, at Perth, of the charge of culpable homicide brought against them.
Some interesting findings arose from the investigation into the drowning of the four miners, supporting the facts that coal mining in this area went back a long way!

-------------------------------------

"The Scotsman"
15 April, 1868
CULPABLE HOMICIDE

James Goodall, coal-master, residing at Woodbine, and Andrew Wallace, residing at Cardenden Colliery, parish of Auchterderran, shire of Fife, were charged with culpable homicide, in so far as the said James Goodall, being tenant or lessee of the coal-work for a period of several years prior to the 28th November 1867, and the said Andrew Wallace being in the employment of the said James Goodall as underground manager or overseer at the pits of the said colliery, known respectively as No. 5 or the engine pit, and No. 6 or the wee pit, and it being well known to both or each or one of the other of the panels that an abandoned or disused pit lay contiguous to the north-east workings of the No. 6 or wee pit, and said disused pit contained a large and dangerous accumulation of water, yet nevertheless the said James Goodall and Andrew Wallace culpably and negligently failed to take due precautions for preventing the water in the said abandoned or disused pit from breaking in upon the said No. 6 or wee pit, whereby William Hunter, James Paden, Patrick Kennedy, and John McCusker or McClusker, who were all employed as miners in the said No. 6 or wee pit, were drowned, and thus culpably bereaved of life by you the said James Goodall and Andrew Wallace, or one or other of you.
The DEAN of FACULTY, with whom was Mr Scott, counsel for the panels, moved that the trial of Goodall and Wallace be separated, as he thought it would be for their interest to do so.
The ADVOCATE-DEPUTE, though not consenting, did not object to the motion.
The Court, under the circumstances, acceded to the motion of the Dean of Faculty; and the public prosecutor decided that Wallace should be tried first - he, having been placed at the bar, pleaded not guilty. Mr Goodall was then removed from the bar, and ordered by the Court to be enclosed as a witness.
The ADVOCATE-DEPUTE then called the following evidence:-
Andrew Scott, pitheadman at Cardenden Colliery - I recollect being on the pit-head - No. 5 - on the 28th November last, at half-past three P.M. I observed some water in the pit, and sent for panel. He came in ten or fifteen minutes. When I looked down the No. 6 or wee pit, I saw water in it quite plain. I found water in it when I went down into the pit. I found the bodies of William Hunter and James Paden. The bodies were not in the water, but had been in it. I saw the body of Patrick Kennedy brought up. It had been in the water. I saw the body of McCusker brought up next day. I was down the wee pit with Mr Simpson, the engineer, but the ... the water came from. We could not get the length of the old waster on account of bad air. Some days after that we got to the old waste. I saw Mr Goodall at the pit on the day the accident happened.
By the DEAN of FACULTY - I have been about eighteen years at the work. The prisoner had been there for about the same period. He went down the pit every day about six o'clock in the morning to look after bad air. He was very attentive to his duty. Before the accident happened there was not an unusual quantity of water pumped out of the pit. There was very little water in the pit, and water had to be sent down to make the pumps work. It was thought that, after the accident happened, that Cardenden mill-dam had burst, but found it was not so. It never occurred to me that there had been an old waste in the neighbourhood of the pit.
By the ADVOCATE-DEPUTE - There was not much water in the waste when it was got to.
By the COURT - Had no knowledge that waste was there. Ewen worked near the place where the water broke in. There was no unusual amount of water in the pit for a year before. It was the duty of Mr Wallace to look after bad air, and he took the usual precautions in his inspection. It was the first accident since I had been there.
John Ewen, sen., miner - It is about three years since I went to Cardenden Colliery. In November last I was working at No. 6 wee pit. On the Monday before the accident I was working in the wee pit on the north-east side. I noticed red coal and water. The coal was made red by the action of the water. I thought there was waste before me. I thought so owing to the redness of the coal. I noticed the redness of the coal eight days before I left. I spoke to Andrew Wallace, William Bannerman, and John Graham about it. I told Wallace that the water was getting heavier every coal that was taken off. I told Wallace to go and look at it. I told him on the Friday night about the water. I left the pit on the following Monday and went to work at another one, either No. 7 or No. 8, called Den Pit. In the pit in which I was working a good deal of water came into it. I spoke to Wallace about the matter several times. I went down into the wee pit after the water was abated in search of the bodies. I never had seen water in the waste before.
By the DEAN of FACULTY - I was sometimes late in going to my work, and sometimes not at all. Seen water let down into the pit to make the pumps draw. I remember the day when Goodall and Wallace went to Cupar to be examined. I did not say to a woman named Birrel that Wallace was gone to Cupar, and hoped he would be hanged and not get back. I said in Wallace's office at the pit mouth that if my wages were lowered I should say a great deal more against Wallace.
Several other miners were afterwards examined, as were Alexander Simpson, civil and mining engineer, Glasgow, who prepared the plans of the No. 6 pit; Andrew Landale, mining engineer, Colquhally, parish of Auchterderran, who stated that there was no appearance on the surface of the ground near the pit into which the water broke of an old coal hill, and in answer to the Dean of Faculty said if there was no tradition of the waste from which the water came, it must be assumed to be of great antiquity. Ralph Moore, Government inspector of mines, Glasgow, examined the pit about twelve hours after the accident, and did not find at his first inspection from whence the water came. He got to the breach some days after, and found the water had come from an old waste.
The ADVOCATE-DEPUTE then addressed the jury, and said he had laid before them all the evidence for the Crown, and he now felt it his duty to withdraw the charge against Mr Wallace; and the jury, accordingly would return a verdict of not guilty.
The DEAN of FACULTY said the public prosecutor had conducted the case for the Crown in a most candid manner, and Mr Wallace would leave the bar without the least stain upon his character.
Lord ARDMILLAN concurred in the course taken by the Advocate-Depute.
The jury then returned a verdict of not guilty, as directed, and Mr Wallace was dismissed simpliciter from the bar.
Mr Goodall was then placed at the bar, when the Advocate-Depute deserted the diet against him, and he accordingly left the bar.

-------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
18 April, 1868

.... It was shown on the trial, from the ancient wooden implements found in the waste, that it must have been over 200 years since it was worked; that it was small in extent, and therefore, likely to be forgotten. ... It further appeared that this was a most unlikely place to find such a waste. The pit was a very deep one so to have been made before engine power was applied to pump water - being about 140 feet deep; whilst in the immediate neighbourhood a hundred acres of the same seam could have been easily worked close to the surface, and where such a waste might have been expected.

-------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Saturday Press"
25 May, 1872
PIT ACCIDENT

On Friday, an accident occurred in the underground workings of the coal pit called the "Big Pit" of the Cardenden Colliery, tenanted by Mr. James Goodall, whereby William McAneny, aged 35 years, residing at Bankhead of Dothan, was severely crushed and bruised about the lower part of the body and thighs, by a quantity of rubbish falling from the roof of the pit. Dr. Malcolm, Lochgelly, who examined McAneny stated that none of his bones were broken.

-------------------------------------

"Dunfermline Press"
22 September, 1900

A rare mention of the pit as 'Spion Kop' is made in this issue, sadly, in a report of the death of Thomas Foley (1½ years old), the son of miner Alexander Foley. The poor child died as a result of swallowing boiling water!

-------------------------------------


Go Home